020-222 practice question 14 of 15

Hydrodensitometry (hydrostatic weighing, underwater weighing) has several sources of error. Which of the following is NOT a common source of error when using this technique to determine body composition?

Full set: 75 questions
Answer options
A: Measurement of the vital capacity of the lungs. Correct answer
B: Interindividual variability in the amount of air in the gastrointestinal tract.
C: Interindividual variability in the density of the individual lean tissue compartment.
D: Measurement of the residual volume.
Correct Answer:
A. Measurement of the vital capacity of the lungs.
Explanation

Hydrodensitometry calculates body volume, which requires accounting for any air that contributes to buoyancy. The air remaining in the lungs after a maximal exhalation, known as the Residual Volume (RV), must be measured or estimated and subtracted from the total volume. An error in the RV measurement is a major source of error in the final body composition estimate. Vital Capacity (VC), the maximum air one can exhale after a full inhalation, is not directly used in the calculation. While VC can be used in equations to predict RV, the measurement of VC itself is not a direct source of error in the hydrodensitometry formula.

Why Incorrect

B. Air in the GI tract adds buoyancy. Since it is difficult to measure, it is often estimated, and interindividual variability introduces error.
C. The conversion of body density to percent fat assumes a constant density of lean tissue (1.100 g/cc), but this varies among individuals.
D. The measurement or prediction of residual volume is a critical step, and inaccuracies in this value are a primary source of error.

References

1. American College of Sports Medicine. (2021). ACSM's Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription (11th ed.). Wolters Kluwer. Chapter 4, p. 83, "Hydrodensitometry (Underwater) Weighing."

2. Nieman, D. C. (2011). Exercise Testing and Prescription: A Health-Related Approach (7th ed.). McGraw-Hill. Chapter 6, p. 168, "Underwater Weighing."

3. Going, S. B. (1996). Densitometry. In Human Body Composition (pp. 3-23). Human Kinetics. (This chapter details sources of error, highlighting RV and the constancy of fat-free mass density).

Scroll to Top