1D0-621 practice question 2 of 15

The Scenario-based design method includes which of the following components?

Full set: 54 questions

Domain Security Auditing and Incident Response

Answer options
A: Testing, redesign, release
B: Discovery, evaluation, prototype
C: Analysis, design, prototype Correct answer
D: Specifications, storyboards, development
Correct Answer:
C. Analysis, design, prototype
Explanation

Scenario-based design is an iterative methodology focused on designing systems from the perspective of user actions and experiences. The core process involves three main components in a cycle. First is Analysis, where designers analyze the current user situation, tasks, and problems, often creating "problem scenarios." Second is Design, where new possibilities and interactions are envisioned and described through "activity scenarios" or "design scenarios." Third is creating a Prototype (ranging from simple storyboards to interactive mockups) which is then evaluated, leading back to further analysis and refinement.

Why Incorrect

A. Testing, redesign, release: "Release" is a software deployment phase that occurs after the design and development cycle is largely complete, not a core component of the design method itself.
B. Discovery, evaluation, prototype: While related to user-centered design, "discovery" is a very broad term. "Analysis" is more specific to the initial phase of scenario-based design, which focuses on analyzing concrete user work situations.
D. Specifications, storyboards, development: This option incorrectly mixes a design artifact (storyboards), a design output (specifications), and a subsequent software lifecycle phase (development), rather than identifying the core components of the method.

References

1. Carroll, J. M. (2000). Making Use: Scenario-Based Design of Human-Computer Interactions. MIT Press. In Chapter 2, "Getting Started with Scenarios," the book outlines the iterative nature of scenario-based design, which involves analyzing problem situations, designing new scenarios of use, and using prototypes for evaluation (pp. 41-64).

2. Rosson, M. B., & Carroll, J. M. (2002). Usability Engineering: Scenario-Based Development of Human-Computer Interaction. Morgan Kaufmann. Chapter 4, "A Scenario-Based Design Process," explicitly details the lifecycle as an iterative process of analysis, design, and prototyping/evaluation (pp. 81-85).

3. Go, J., & Carroll, J. M. (2004). Scenario-Based Design. In W. S. Bainbridge (Ed.), Berkshire Encyclopedia of Human-Computer Interaction (Vol. 2, pp. 636-641). The text describes the process as starting with "problem analysis," moving to "activity design," and then to "information and interaction design," which are prototyped and evaluated. This directly maps to the analysis, design, and prototype cycle.

Scroll to Top