AICP practice question 25 of 25

A city council has obtained a copy of an innovative land use regulation used by a city in anotherstate. A planner has been asked to investigate the feasibility of adopting a similar law. The planner’s first step should be to:

Full set: 170 questions
Answer options
A: Research case law for relevant court decisions.
B: Prepare a draft regulation using the other city’s regulation as a model.
C: Review the state’s enabling legislation. Correct answer
D: Hold a community meeting to present the concept.
Correct Answer:
C. Review the state’s enabling legislation.
Explanation

The authority for a local government to enact land use regulations is granted by the state through enabling legislation. This principle, known as Dillon's Rule in many states, holds that municipalities only have powers expressly granted to them by the state. Therefore, before considering the adoption of an innovative regulation from another jurisdiction, a planner's essential first step is to verify that their state's enabling laws authorize the municipality to implement such a tool. Without this legal authority, any subsequent effort would be invalid.

Why Incorrect

A. Researching case law is a necessary step for legal review, but it should follow the initial confirmation of statutory authority from enabling legislation.
B. Drafting a regulation is premature. It is inefficient to draft a law that the city may have no legal power to enact.
D. Public engagement is critical, but it should occur after the planner has confirmed the legal feasibility of the proposed regulation.

References

1. Levy, J. M. (2017). Contemporary Urban Planning (11th ed.). Routledge. Chapter 5, "The Legal Basis of Planning," p. 108. The chapter emphasizes that local planning and land-use controls are "exercised only under powers granted by state government" through enabling legislation.

2. Mandelker, D. R., & Tarlock, A. D. (2021). Planning and Control of Land Development: Cases and Materials (10th ed.). Carolina Academic Press. Chapter 2, Section 2, "The Standard State Zoning Enabling Act," pp. 61-63. This section details how state acts provide the fundamental legal authority for local zoning.

3. Hoch, C. J., Dalton, L. C., & So, F. S. (Eds.). (2000). The Practice of Local Government Planning (3rd ed.). International City/County Management Association (ICMA). Chapter 4, "Planning and the Law," p. 80. The text states, "The first place to look for the source of a local government's power to plan and regulate land use is in the state enabling statutes."

Scroll to Top