ASIS-PCI practice question 7 of 25

A defendant's res gestae statements to police are:

Full set: 141 questions
Answer options
A: admissible Correct answer
B: not admissible
C: hearsay
D: admissible only of appropriate warnings have been given
Correct Answer:
A. admissible
Explanation

Res gestae is a Latin term for "things done." In legal terms, it refers to statements made spontaneously and contemporaneously with an event. These statements, often called "excited utterances" or "present sense impressions" under modern evidence rules, are considered inherently reliable because their spontaneity leaves little opportunity for reflection or fabrication. Due to this perceived reliability, res gestae statements constitute a well-established exception to the general rule that prohibits hearsay evidence. Consequently, a defendant's spontaneous res gestae statement to the police is admissible in court.

Why Incorrect

B. not admissible: This is incorrect. The doctrine of res gestae exists specifically to allow for the admission of such spontaneous statements as an exception to evidence rules.
C. hearsay: While technically an out-of-court statement (hearsay), this answer is incomplete. The crucial point is that it is an admissible exception to the hearsay rule.
D. admissible only of appropriate warnings have been given: This is incorrect. The admissibility of a spontaneous res gestae statement is not contingent on prior warnings (e.g., Miranda rights), which apply to custodial interrogations, not spontaneous utterances.

References

1. Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 803. Exceptions to the Rule Against Hearsay. The concepts historically covered by res gestae are codified primarily under:

Rule 803(1) Present Sense Impression: "A statement describing or explaining an event or condition, made while or immediately after the declarant perceived it."

Rule 803(2) Excited Utterance: "A statement relating to a startling event or condition, made while the declarant was under the stress of excitement that it caused."

These rules establish the admissibility of such statements.

2. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute (LII). In its Wex Legal Dictionary entry for "Res Gestae," it states: "Res gestae is a Latin phrase meaning 'things done.' In the law of evidence, res gestae is a theory under which certain hearsay statements may be admitted as exceptions to the hearsay rule." This confirms that such statements are admissible exceptions.

3. Orenstein, A. (2011). The Persistence of the Res Gestae. Chicago-Kent Law Review, 86(2), 635-666. This academic article discusses the evolution and application of the res gestae doctrine, noting its function as a pathway for admitting otherwise excludable hearsay evidence. Section II, "The Traditional Res Gestae Exceptions," details how these spontaneous statements are treated as admissible.

Scroll to Top