ASIS-PCI practice question 15 of 25

When an interviewee makes a statement such as "Let's suppose I'm guilty," the interviewer should:

Full set: 141 questions
Answer options
A: document an admission of guilt
B: respond calmly.
C: recognize this as a diversion technique by the Interviewee Correct answer
D: apply pressure to obtain a written statement.
Correct Answer:
C. recognize this as a diversion technique by the Interviewee
Explanation

The statement "Let's suppose I'm guilty" is a classic hypothetical used by deceptive subjects. It is not a confession but a tactic to gauge the interviewer's reaction, test the strength of the evidence, or divert the interview's focus. The primary and most crucial step for the interviewer is to recognize this statement for what it is: a diversionary or testing technique. This recognition allows the interviewer to maintain control and steer the conversation back to factual matters without overreacting or misinterpreting the statement as an admission.

Why Incorrect

A. A hypothetical statement is not a legal admission of guilt and should never be documented as such.
B. While remaining calm is important, simply being calm is a general demeanor, not a specific, strategic response to this tactic.
D. Applying pressure is premature and coercive, as no admission has been made; this could jeopardize the entire investigation.

References

1. ASIS International. (2012). Protection of Assets: Investigations. Alexandria, VA: ASIS International. In the chapter on "Interviewing and Interrogation," the text discusses verbal behaviors indicative of deception. Hypothetical statements are described as a method for a deceptive person to talk about the crime without making a direct admission, often to test the interviewer's knowledge and reaction (Section 3.4.3, Verbal Cues).

2. Vrij, A. (2008). Detecting lies and deceit: Pitfalls and opportunities (2nd ed.). John Wiley & Sons. Vrij's research on verbal cues of deception explains that deceptive individuals often use distancing language and hypothetical framing ("what if," "suppose that") to psychologically separate themselves from the act being discussed. Recognizing this as a strategic utterance is key for the investigator (Chapter 5, Verbal Characteristics of Deception).

3. Zulawski, D. E., & Wicklander, D. E. (2002). Practical aspects of interview and interrogation (2nd ed.). CRC Press. This foundational text in investigative interviewing identifies such hypothetical questions as "trial questions" or "baiting questions" from the subject. The authors advise that the interviewer should recognize these as attempts to gain information and not treat them as admissions (Chapter 11, Behavior Symptoms of the Deceptive).

Scroll to Top