ASIS-PCI practice question 25 of 25

With regard to evidence searches, which statement is FALSE?

Full set: 141 questions
Answer options
A: search must be timely.
B: Physical evidence cannot be overdocumented.
C: A search may be either a cautious search or a vigorous search
D: The best search options are the quickest and the simplest. Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. The best search options are the quickest and the simplest.
Explanation

The statement that the best search options are the quickest and simplest is false. In professional investigations, the primary goal of an evidence search is to be thorough, methodical, and systematic to ensure all potential evidence is located and recovered without contamination or destruction. The choice of a search method (e.g., grid, spiral, zone) is dictated by the specific circumstances of the scene, such as its size, location, and the type of evidence sought. While efficiency is a consideration, it is secondary to the effectiveness and legal defensibility of the search, which often requires more time and complexity than the "quickest and simplest" approach would allow.

Why Incorrect

A. search must be timely. This is a true statement. Delays in searching can lead to the degradation, contamination, loss, or intentional removal of evidence, compromising the investigation.
B. Physical evidence cannot be overdocumented. This is a true statement. Thorough and meticulous documentation (notes, photographs, sketches, logs) is critical to preserving the context of the evidence and ensuring its admissibility in legal proceedings.
C. A search may be either a cautious search or a vigorous search. This is a true statement. The intensity of a search is adapted to the situation; a cautious search is used for fragile or trace evidence, while a more vigorous search may be appropriate elsewhere.

References

1. Fischer, R. J., & Halibozek, E. P. (2019). Introduction to Security (10th ed.). Butterworth-Heinemann.

Chapter 11, "Information Security and Investigations," emphasizes that investigations must be conducted with a focus on detail, accuracy, and thoroughness. It implicitly refutes the idea that "quickest and simplest" is best, instead highlighting the need for methodical processes to ensure evidence integrity and admissibility.

2. National Institute of Justice. (2013). Crime Scene Investigation: A Guide for Law Enforcement. (NCJ 178280).

Section D, "Conduct a detailed search," states, "The search for physical evidence is conducted in a systematic manner... The thoroughness of the search has a direct bearing on the success of the investigation." (p. 15). This guide details various systematic search patterns (grid, spiral, etc.) that prioritize thoroughness over speed and simplicity.

3. Swanson, C. R., Chamelin, N. C., Territo, L., & Taylor, R. W. (2011). Criminal Investigation (11th ed.). McGraw-Hill.

Chapter 4, "The Crime Scene Search and Recording," discusses the importance of selecting an appropriate search pattern based on the environment. The text stresses that "a crime scene search must be methodical and systematic" and that "what is important is that the search be thorough." (p. 93). This directly contradicts the notion that the quickest and simplest methods are best.

4. ASIS International. (2021). Protection of Assets (POA), Investigations Volume.

The principles outlined in the Investigations volume consistently stress the need for methodical, legally sound, and thorough investigative processes. The section on "Collecting and Preserving Evidence" details procedures that require careful planning and execution, not speed or simplicity, to maintain the chain of custody and ensure the evidence is viable for legal proceedings.

Scroll to Top