CCII practice question 10 of 25

The preservation letter does not legally require the ISP to turn over its records.

Full set: 130 questions
Answer options
A:

A. True

B:

B. False

Correct Answer:
TRUE
Explanation

The statement is correct. A preservation letter, often referred to as a "litigation hold" or a "2703(f) letter" under the U.S. Stored Communications Act, serves a single, specific legal function: it compels a service provider (like an ISP) to preserve and prevent the destruction of specified electronic records in its possession. It does not, by itself, authorize or legally require the provider to disclose or turn over that information to the requesting party. A separate and distinct legal instrument, such as a search warrant, subpoena, or court order, is required to compel the actual disclosure of the preserved data. The preservation letter ensures that evidence is not deleted during the time it takes to secure the appropriate legal order for its release.

Why Incorrect

The "False" option is incorrect because it conflates the legal requirements for data preservation with those for data disclosure. These are two separate legal actions under statutes like the Stored Communications Act. A preservation letter has a lower legal threshold and only freezes the data in place; it does not grant access to it. Affirming that the letter requires the ISP to turn over records would be a fundamental misinterpretation of its legal scope and purpose in digital investigations.

References

1. Official Vendor/Government Documentation:

United States Department of Justice. (2009). Searching and Seizing Computers and Obtaining Electronic Evidence in Criminal Investigations (3rd ed.). Computer Crime & Intellectual Property Section, Criminal Division.

Reference: Chapter 3, Section III.A.1, "Preservation of Evidence." The manual states, "Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2703(f), a provider of electronic communication service or remote computing service shall, in response to a request from a government entity, preserve records and other evidence in its possession for 90 days... A § 2703(f) letter does not authorize the government to access the preserved information; rather, agents must obtain the appropriate legal process (i.e., a search warrant, a § 2703(d) order, or a subpoena) to compel disclosure of the preserved information."

2. Peer-reviewed Academic Publications:

Kerr, O. S. (2013). The Law of Electronic Surveillance in the United States. In Cybercrime and Security (pp. 11-28). Springer, Boston, MA.

Reference: In discussions of the Stored Communications Act (SCA), the distinction is made clear. "The SCA also includes a preservation provision, 18 U.S.C. 2703(f), that allows the government to send a letter to a provider ordering it to preserve records for 90 days pending the issuance of a search warrant or other legal process. The preservation letter does not itself require disclosure; it only requires that the provider not destroy the records." (Paraphrased from typical analyses of § 2703(f) in Kerr's work).

3. University Courseware:

Stanford University, School of Law. (Course: Cyberlaw). Reading Materials on Government Surveillance and the Stored Communications Act.

Reference: Course materials frequently analyze 18 U.S.C. § 2703, emphasizing the procedural separation between preservation and compulsion. Lecture notes and assigned readings clarify that § 2703(f) provides a mechanism to prevent spoliation of evidence but does not substitute for the warrant, court order (§ 2703(d)), or subpoena required by sections § 2703(a), (b), and (c) to obtain the content or non-content records.

Scroll to Top