CIMAPRA19-F02-1 practice question 6 of 35

LM has made the following share purchases during the year: • Purchased 55% of the equity share capital of OP. • Purchased 45% of the equity share…

Full set: 266 questions
LM has made the following share purchases during the year: • Purchased 55% of the equity share capital of OP. • Purchased 45% of the equity share capital of QR. LM have the power to appoint the majority of board members on the QR board. • Purchased 30% of the equity share capital of ST. LM is represented by one director on the main board of ST which has five members in total. The other 70% of ST's equity share capital is owned by a single company, UV. The Managing Director has told you that OP has performed well, but both QR and ST have not performed as expected. He is therefore pleased that OP will be included as a subsidiary and that QR and ST will only be included as investments in the group financial statements. In accordance with the ethical principle of professional competence and due care how should the investments in OP, QR and ST be treated in the group financial statements?
Answer options
A: OP and QR should be consolidated and ST should be equity accounted. Correct answer
B: OP should be consolidated and QR and ST should be equity accounted.
C: OP should be consolidated, QR should be equity accounted and ST should be valued at cost.
D: OP and QR should be equity accounted and ST should be valued at cost.
Correct Answer:
A. OP and QR should be consolidated and ST should be equity accounted.
Explanation

The ethical principle of professional competence and due care requires applying the correct accounting standards. According to IFRS 10, an investor controls an investee when it has power over it. LM controls OP through its 55% majority shareholding. LM also controls QR, despite holding only 45% of the shares, because its power to appoint the majority of the board gives it power over QR's relevant activities. Therefore, both OP and QR are subsidiaries and must be consolidated. Under IAS 28, significant influence is the power to participate in policy decisions. LM's 30% holding and board representation in ST create a presumption of significant influence, making ST an associate. Associates must be accounted for using the equity method.

Why Incorrect

B. This is incorrect because LM has control over QR through its power to appoint the board, which requires consolidation, not equity accounting.
C. This is incorrect as LM controls QR (requiring consolidation) and has significant influence over ST (requiring equity accounting), not valuation at cost.
D. This is incorrect as LM has control over both OP and QR, which mandates consolidation, not the equity method.

References

1. IFRS Foundation. (2021). IFRS 10 Consolidated Financial Statements.

Paragraph 7: "An investor controls an investee if and only if the investor has all the following: (a) power over the investee...".

Paragraph B19: States that rights to appoint

reassign or remove members of an investee’s key management personnel who can direct relevant activities are an indicator of power. This supports the consolidation of QR.

2. IFRS Foundation. (2021). IAS 28 Investments in Associates and Joint Ventures.

Paragraph 5: Defines significant influence and states that if an investor holds 20 per cent or more of the voting power

it is presumed that the investor has significant influence

unless it can be clearly demonstrated that this is not the case.

Paragraph 6(a): Lists "representation on the board of directors or equivalent governing body of the investee" as evidence of significant influence. This supports the equity accounting treatment for ST.

3. University of Cambridge

Judge Business School. (2020). MFin Accounting Core Course: Lecture 5 - Group Accounting.

Section 3.2

"Control": Explains that control under IFRS 10 is not solely based on majority shareholding but on the existence of power

which can be evidenced by rights such as appointing the majority of the board of directors.

Section 4.1

"Significant Influence": Clarifies that holdings between 20% and 50% coupled with board representation typically lead to an associate classification requiring the equity method.

Scroll to Top