CIMAPRO19-P02-1 practice question 2 of 30

Under the absorption costing system, which simply allocates our entire amount of production overheads based on machine hours, we have found that out…

Full set: 202 questions
Under the absorption costing system, which simply allocates our entire amount of production overheads based on machine hours, we have found that out of our 4 products, 2 are profitable, 1 breaks even and 1 is making a loss. Model D the most recent addition to the range is making a large loss after the price of a major component rose dramatically. Model A is only just breaking now too as costs have risen. The only two products making profit are Models B and C. These two require the least about of machine hours so this makes sense. However, the management have a few reservations. They cannot understand how B is so profitable. It requires several more stages of production than the other models and a whole day longer to be customised by an expert. Select the correct answer from the list below that can help to explain this situation.
Answer options
A: ABC would show that only a small amount of our overheads are based on machine hours. Correct answer
B: ABC could have shown that some products are selling poorly and should be discontinued.
C: ABC would show that if overheads are shared equally that model B would be less profitable.
Correct Answer:
A. ABC would show that only a small amount of our overheads are based on machine hours.
Explanation

The company's current absorption costing system uses a single, volume-related cost driver (machine hours). This method inaccurately allocates overheads, especially when products have different complexities. Model B, despite low machine hours, is complex, requiring more production stages and expert customization. These activities generate significant overheads (e.g., setup, quality control, material handling) that are not driven by machine hours. Activity-Based Costing (ABC) would identify these activities and their true cost drivers. It would likely show that a large portion of overheads is unrelated to machine hours, and would reallocate these costs to Model B, revealing its true, and likely lower, profitability.

Why Incorrect

B. This states a potential consequence of implementing ABC, not the underlying reason why the current costing system is providing misleading information about Model B's profitability.
C. This statement is incorrect. Activity-Based Costing does not share overheads equally; it allocates them based on the consumption of specific activities, which is fundamentally different from an equal share.

References

1. Drury, C. (2018). Management and Cost Accounting (10th ed.). Cengage Learning. In Chapter 5, "Activity-Based Costing," it is explained that traditional volume-based costing systems can report distorted costs. "Products that are produced in small batches and are complex in design will consume a high level of resources per unit... A traditional costing system that relies on a single volume-based overhead rate will understate the cost of these products" (p. 114). This directly supports the scenario where Model B's complexity is not captured by machine hours.

2. Kaplan, R. S., & Cooper, R. (1988). Measure Costs Right: Make the Right Decisions. Harvard Business Review, 66(5), 96-103. This foundational article on ABC highlights that as the diversity of products and production processes increases, overhead allocation based on a single driver like machine hours becomes increasingly inaccurate. The article argues that many overheads are related to transactions (like setups or purchase orders) and complexity, not volume, which explains why a complex product like Model B can be mis-costed.

3. CIMA. (2019). CIMA P2 Advanced Management Accounting Official Study Text. Kaplan Publishing. The chapter on Activity-Based Costing states that ABC "recognises that overhead costs are not all related to production and sales volume" and that it "traces overheads to products by identifying the cost drivers that cause the costs to be incurred." This principle directly validates that ABC would show that overheads are driven by more than just machine hours, as stated in option A.

Scroll to Top