DCPP-01 practice question 2 of 25

APEC privacy framework envisages common principles such as Notice, Collection limitation, Use Limitation, Access and Correction, Security/Safeguards, and Accountability. But it differs from the EU Data Protection Directive in which of the below aspect?

Full set: 122 questions
Answer options
A: APEC privacy framework does not deal with the usage of personal information
B: APEC privacy framework does not mandate the binding treaties or directives for member countries Correct answer
C: APEC privacy framework does not have a provision for co-operation between privacy enforcement agencies of members
D: APEC privacy framework does not deal with e-commerce
Correct Answer:
B. APEC privacy framework does not mandate the binding treaties or directives for member countries
Explanation

The fundamental difference between the APEC Privacy Framework and the EU's Data Protection Directive (and its successor, the GDPR) lies in their legal nature. The EU framework is a "hard law" approach, where directives and regulations are legally binding on member states, requiring them to implement specific national laws. In contrast, the APEC framework is a "soft law" or principles-based model. It is a voluntary system that encourages member economies to adopt consistent privacy protections through their own domestic laws and policies but does not impose a binding international treaty or legislative mandate. This approach promotes interoperability among diverse legal systems rather than strict harmonization.

Why Incorrect

A. The APEC framework explicitly includes the "Use Limitation Principle," which governs how personal information can be used, directly contradicting this statement.
C. The APEC framework established the Cross-border Privacy Enforcement Arrangement (CPEA) specifically to foster cooperation among privacy enforcement authorities of member economies.
D. The APEC framework was created with the primary goal of facilitating electronic commerce by building trust in cross-border data flows.

References

1. APEC Privacy Framework (2015). APEC Secretariat. In Part I: Preamble, the document describes itself as a "framework" intended to "promote a consistent approach" and "encourage the development of appropriate information privacy protections," highlighting its non-binding, cooperative nature rather than a mandatory directive. (Available on the official APEC website).

2. Kuner, C. (2012). The European Union and the APEC Cross Border Privacy Rules system: a new basis for an EU-APEC dialogue on data privacy. International Data Privacy Law, 2(3), 158–172. Section 2, "The APEC CBPR system," describes the APEC system as an "accountability-based system" that is "not based on a binding international treaty." https://doi.org/10.1093/idpl/ips010

3. U.S. Department of Commerce, International Trade Administration. "APEC Cross-Border Privacy Rules System." The official description states, "The APEC CBPR System is a voluntary, accountability-based system that facilitates privacy-respecting data flows among APEC economies." This explicitly confirms the voluntary (non-mandatory) nature of the framework. (Available on the official U.S. ITA website, privacy-shield-archive section).

Scroll to Top