GH-900 practice question 1 of 15

What is the difference between an organization member and an outside collaborator?

Full set: 144 questions
Answer options
A: Organization base permissions do not apply to outside collaborators. Correct answer
B: Two-factor authentication (2FA) is not required for outside collaborators.
C: Outside collaborators cannot be given the admin role on a repository.
D: Outside collaborators do not consume paid licenses.
Correct Answer:
A. Organization base permissions do not apply to outside collaborators.
Explanation

The fundamental distinction between an organization member and an outside collaborator lies in the scope of their permissions. Organization members are subject to organization-wide settings, including base permissions, which grant a default level of access to all repositories within the organization. In contrast, an outside collaborator is not a member and is unaffected by these base permissions. Their access is granted explicitly on a per-repository basis, allowing for more granular and limited control without making them a full member of the organization.

Why Incorrect

B. Two-factor authentication (2FA) can be, and often is, required for outside collaborators by an organization's security policy to access its repositories.
C. Outside collaborators can be granted any permission level on a specific repository, including the admin role, just like an organization member.
D. Outside collaborators consume a paid license seat if they are given access to a private or internal repository under a paid plan (e.g., GitHub Enterprise).

References

1. GitHub Docs, "Roles in an organization." This document defines the roles and explicitly states, "An outside collaborator is a person who isn't a member of your organization, but has access to one or more of your organization's repositories." This establishes the core difference.

2. GitHub Docs, "Setting base permissions for an organization." This page clarifies that base permissions apply to "organization members," confirming that this setting does not extend to outside collaborators. It states, "You can give organization members read, write, or admin permissions to all of your organization's repositories."

3. GitHub Docs, "Requiring two-factor authentication in your organization." This source directly refutes option B, stating, "When you require use of two-factor authentication for your organization, members, outside collaborators, and billing managers... who do not use 2FA will be removed from the organization..."

4. GitHub Docs, "About per-user pricing." This document invalidates option D by explaining the billing model: "GitHub bills for... Every outside collaborator on at least one private or internal repository, not including forks."

Scroll to Top