HCVA0-003 practice question 26 of 35

When unsealing Vault, each Shamir unseal key should be entered:

Full set: 285 questions
Answer options
A: Sequentially from one system that all of the administrators are in front of
B: By different administrators each connecting from different computers Correct answer
C: While encrypted with each administrators PGP key
D: At the command line in one single command
Correct Answer:
B. By different administrators each connecting from different computers
Explanation

The security model of Vault's Shamir's Secret Sharing is founded on the principle of distributed trust. To uphold this principle during the critical unsealing operation, each keyholder (administrator) should provide their unique key share independently. Performing this from different computers prevents a single point of compromise, such as a compromised workstation or a malicious shoulder-surfer, from capturing multiple key shares. The unseal process is stateful and designed to receive keys one by one from different operators until the defined threshold is met, thereby reconstructing the master key and unsealing Vault. This operational practice is a crucial part of a secure "unseal ceremony."

Why Incorrect

A. This centralizes the unseal process, creating a single point of compromise and defeating the purpose of distributing the keys among multiple operators.
C. The vault operator unseal command expects the raw unseal key. While the connection to Vault should be secured with TLS, PGP encryption is not a native part of this specific workflow.
D. The vault operator unseal command is stateful and designed to be executed multiple times, once for each key share, until the threshold is met. It does not accept multiple keys in one command.

References

1. HashiCorp Learn, "Seal/Unseal Vault" Tutorial: This official tutorial describes the unseal process. It states, "The unseal process is performed by running vault operator unseal... The unseal process is stateful. Each key-holder enters their portion of the master key." This implies separate, individual actions, aligning with the distributed trust model.

Source: HashiCorp Learn, Vault - Seal/Unseal, "Unseal Vault" section.

2. HashiCorp Vault Official Documentation, vault operator unseal Command: The command's usage documentation demonstrates that it accepts a single key argument (vault operator unseal ). This confirms that keys must be entered in separate command executions.

Source: HashiCorp, Vault Documentation, CLI Commands, operator unseal.

3. HashiCorp Vault Official Documentation, "Concepts - Architecture": The architecture documentation explains the "security barrier." It details that the master key is protected and requires a quorum of unseal keys to be reconstructed. The entire design philosophy supports the operational separation of duties and keys.

Source: HashiCorp, Vault Documentation, Concepts, "Architecture," Security Barrier section.

Scroll to Top