ICGB practice question 30 of 30

According to a manager it takes an average weekday commute of 39 minutes with a Standard Deviation of 7 minutes for the employees to get to work when…

Full set: 200 questions
According to a manager it takes an average weekday commute of 39 minutes with a Standard Deviation of 7 minutes for the employees to get to work when they use their personal vehicles for their office commute while management set a policy of not more than 40 minutes for their daily one- way commute. A survey conducted one day on 70 employees showed an average of 34 minutes commuting time using the metro public transportation system with a Standard Deviation of 21 minutes. For the employees choosing to increase their chances to come on time using personal transportation their variation should be reduced to ___________?
Answer options
A: 1 minute
B: 6 minutes
C: 3.5 minutes Correct answer
D: Eliminate it to 0.0 minutes
Correct Answer:
C. 3.5 minutes
Explanation

The goal is to find the new standard deviation (σ) for personal transport that yields the same on-time probability as the MPTS. First, calculate the Z-score for the MPTS: Z = (40 - 34) / 21 ≈ 0.286. To match this performance with personal transport, we set its Z-score calculation equal to 0.286 and solve for the new σ: Z = (Specification Limit - Mean) / σ 0.286 = (40 - 39) / σ 0.286 = 1 / σ σ = 1 / 0.286 ≈ 3.5 minutes. Reducing the variation to a standard deviation of 3.5 minutes would make the on-time probability for both methods equal.

Why Incorrect

A. A standard deviation of 1 minute would result in a Z-score of 1, a much higher probability (84.1%) than required to match the MPTS.
B. A standard deviation of 6 minutes results in a Z-score of 0.167, which is a lower probability (56.6%) than the MPTS.
D. Eliminating variation to 0.0 is practically impossible and represents an extreme solution not implied by the need to simply "increase chances."

References

1. The Pennsylvania State University. (n.d.). STAT 414: Introduction to Probability Theory. Section 4.3, "The Normal Distribution." Retrieved from https://online.stat.psu.edu/stat414/lesson/4/4.3. The course material covers the manipulation of the Z-score formula Z = (X - μ) / σ to solve for an unknown variable like σ.

2. Montgomery, D. C. (2013). Introduction to Statistical Quality Control (7th ed.). Wiley. Chapter 9, "Process Capability Analysis," pp. 405-408, demonstrates how process parameters (mean, standard deviation) relate to specification limits and performance metrics.

3. MIT OpenCourseWare. (2011). 15.075J Statistical Thinking and Data Analysis. Fall 2011. Lecture 6, "Continuous Random Variables." The lecture notes cover the standardization of normal random variables and the components of the Z-score formula.

Scroll to Top