ICGB practice question 17 of 30

Due to excessive pollution, GREEN Solutions Inc. is considering subsidizing public transportation to work for its employees. According to the manager…

Full set: 200 questions
Due to excessive pollution, GREEN Solutions Inc. is considering subsidizing public transportation to work for its employees. According to the manager it takes an average weekday commute of 39 minutes with a Standard Deviation of 7 minutes for the employees to get to work while they use their personal vehicles for their office commute while the management set a policy of not more than 40 minutes for their daily one-way commute. A survey conducted one day on 70 employees showed an average of 34 minutes commuting time using the metro public transportation system with a Standard Deviation of 21 minutes. Assuming a Normal Distribution for the commute times by either personal or public transportation, which of these is true?
Answer options
A: The probability that they would arrive on time using personal vehicles is much higher than using the metro public transportation system (MPTS)
B: The probability that they would arrive on time using the MPTS is much higher than using their personal vehicles Correct answer
C: The two probabilities are about the same excepting in one case the consistency is higher than the other
D: We need to compile more data around weekends to incorporate for traffic differences
E: When Standard Deviation is higher the probability goes down and so the MPTS is worse
Correct Answer:
B. The probability that they would arrive on time using the MPTS is much higher than using their personal vehicles
Explanation

To determine the probability of arriving on time (≤ 40 minutes), we calculate the Z-score for each transportation method. For personal vehicles: Z = (40 - 39) / 7 ≈ 0.143. The probability P(X ≤ 40) is approximately 55.7%. For the Metro Public Transportation System (MPTS): Z = (40 - 34) / 21 ≈ 0.286. The probability P(X ≤ 40) is approximately 61.3%. Since 61.3% > 55.7%, the probability of arriving on time is higher when using the MPTS, despite its larger standard deviation. The lower average commute time for the MPTS has a greater positive impact in this scenario.

Why Incorrect

A. The calculated probability for personal vehicles (55.7%) is lower than for the MPTS (61.3%), making this statement false.
C. The probabilities (55.7% vs. 61.3%) are not the same, and the consistency (Standard Deviation) is vastly different (7 vs. 21).
D. The problem is explicitly about weekday commutes; weekend data is irrelevant to the question asked.
E. A higher Standard Deviation does not automatically mean a lower probability; the mean's relationship to the specification limit is also critical.

References

1. Montgomery, D. C. (2013). Introduction to Statistical Quality Control (7th ed.). Wiley. Chapter 4, Section 4.3, "The Normal Distribution," discusses the calculation of probabilities using the standard normal distribution (Z-score).

2. The Pennsylvania State University. (n.d.). STAT 501: Regression Methods. Lesson 1: Simple Linear Regression, Section 1.2 - The Normal Distribution. Retrieved from https://online.stat.psu.edu/stat501/lesson/1/1.2. This resource explains how to calculate Z-scores and find corresponding probabilities.

3. University of Texas at Austin. (n.d.). Six Sigma Green Belt Body of Knowledge. Module: Measure Phase, "Process Capability." This type of university-level courseware details the use of mean, standard deviation, and specification limits to calculate performance metrics like Z-scores.

Scroll to Top