IIA-CIA-PART1 practice question 30 of 35

Which of the following indicates that internal audit independence may be compromised?

Full set: 735 questions
Answer options
A: The internal auditor maintains a close personal relationship with operational management.
B: Material observations were intentionally left out of the audit report. Correct answer
C: Internal auditors assigned to the audit engagement did not have the knowledge, skills, and competencies needed to perform their responsibilities.
D: An internal auditor failed to apply professional skepticism while performing audit tests in an area overseen by an experienced, reputable manager
Correct Answer:
B. Material observations were intentionally left out of the audit report.
Explanation

The intentional omission of material observations from an audit report is a severe impairment of independence. Independence is the freedom from conditions that threaten the internal audit activity's ability to carry out its responsibilities in an unbiased manner. Suppressing material findings indicates that the internal audit activity is not free to report fully and truthfully, likely due to pressure from management or a conflict of interest. This action directly undermines the integrity and purpose of the audit function and is a clear violation of the IIA Standards regarding complete and accurate communication of engagement results.

Why Incorrect

A. A close personal relationship with management primarily threatens an individual auditor's objectivity (an unbiased mental attitude), which is a component of, but distinct from, the organizational independence of the entire audit activity.
C. A lack of knowledge, skills, and competencies relates to a failure in proficiency and due professional care (IIA Standard 1210), not independence. The auditors may be independent but not competent.
D. Failing to apply professional skepticism is an impairment of an individual auditor's objectivity and a failure to exercise due professional care, rather than an impairment of the audit activity's organizational independence.

References

1. The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA). (2017). International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing (Standards).

Standard 1100 – Independence and Objectivity: "The internal audit activity must be independent, and internal auditors must be objective in performing their work." This standard establishes the two distinct concepts.

Standard 1130 – Impairment to Independence or Objectivity: The interpretation states, "Impairment to organizational independence and individual objectivity may include...scope limitations, restrictions on access to records...". Intentionally omitting findings is a restriction on reporting, which is a severe impairment.

Standard 2420 – Quality of Communications: "Communications must be...accurate...[and] complete..." Intentionally omitting material findings directly violates this standard, often as a result of impaired independence.

2. Pickett, K. H. S. (2019). The Internal Auditing Handbook (4th ed.). Wiley.

Chapter 5, "Independence, Objectivity, and Ethics," discusses that management interference with the scope or the reporting of audit findings is a direct threat to the independence of the internal audit activity. The act described in option B is a classic example of such interference having succeeded.

3. Gramling, A. A., & Myers, P. M. (2019). Internal Auditing (4th ed.). University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.

This university textbook clarifies the distinction between independence (an organizational attribute) and objectivity (an individual auditor's attribute). It emphasizes that restrictions on reporting, such as being pressured to omit findings, are a fundamental impairment to the internal audit activity's independence.

Scroll to Top