ITIL-SOA practice question 9 of 10

Scenario A large, privately owned company has an internal IT organization that runs most of its IT operations from the head office. There has been a…

Full set: 14 questions
Scenario A large, privately owned company has an internal IT organization that runs most of its IT operations from the head office. There has been a history of confusion about what is required from the services and what has actually been achieved, particularly from a warranty perspective. This has resulted in a strained relationship between the business units and the IT organization. Some service-based agreements exist between IT and the customers, where all levels of response to incidents were set to the same targets. Availability targets have not been reviewed for at least two years. There have been a number of complaints by key customers claiming that the IT staff have been resolving incidents and implementing change requests based on operational ease rather than business priority. This is despite operationally robust processes being in place for incident, change and problem management. A plan has been put in place to improve the level of the IT service delivered to the organization. Retirement of the post-holder meant that the first action was to appoint a new IT director. The opportunity was taken to select a candidate from an external organization, who was committed to the ITIL framework. The new IT director believes that good IT service management practices are essential. The IT director plans to implement many of the service management processes and has already overseen the creation of a basic service catalogue. The IT director is sure that many of the current issues can be rectified through the implementation of service level management (SLM) and has therefore directed that service level agreements (SLA) be introduced for the services provided before moving onto other areas. You have been asked to lead the project to establish SLAs for the IT services. Refer to the Scenario. Which one of the following sequence of activities would be the BEST approach to establishing service levels agreements (SLA) in the organization?
Answer options
A: Identify all of the services currently delivered using the service catalogue. Define a primarily customer-based approach to implementing service levels agreements (SLAs). Using a pre-prepared pro-forma service level requirements (SLR) template, meet with the appropriate customer representatives to discuss and document their service level requirements. Arrange meetings with the appropriate IT teams, specifically those involved in incident, availability and capacity management, to discuss, document and agree the levels of service required. Draft agreements from these discussions are then reviewed by service operations to ensure that no existing agreements will be compromised and, once this has been confirmed, the SLA is formally reviewed, agreed, and signed by both the customer and IT. The service level targets are then formally communicated, monitored, reported upon and reviewed at the agreed intervals. Correct answer
B: Identify all the services currently delivered using the service catalogue. Define a primarily service-based approach to implementing service level agreements. Using the service templates already in use, meet with the appropriate customer representatives and, after discussion, produce formal SLRs which document the levels of service that the customer needs. Arrange meetings with the appropriate IT teams, specifically those involved in incident, availability and capacity management, to discuss, document and communicate the levels of service required. From these discussions operational level agreements (OLAs) are then produced. The SLRs and OLAs can be formally monitored, reported upon and reviewed at the agreed intervals.
C: Meet with the IT operations team, specifically, those involved in incident, availability and capacity management, to define what level of service they can offer to the business against each service in the service catalogue. Meet with the appropriate customer representatives to give them a clear understanding of the levels of service IT can offer. Produce and agree an SLA and ensure it is signed by representatives of both parties. Document and agree OLAs with the service operation teams. Ensure all parties understand their responsibilities and enforce penalties for non-compliance. Once both agreements have been signed, all service level targets are then formally monitored and reviewed.
D: Identify all of the services currently delivered using the service catalogue. Define a primarily service-based approach to implementing service level agreements. Meet with the appropriate business representatives and, after discussion, produce a formal SLA that guarantees the levels of service that the business needs. Arrange meetings with the appropriate IT teams, specifically those involved in incident, availability and capacity management, to inform them of the service levels you have agreed Document and agree OLAs with the service operation teams. Once these are agreed and signed the OLAs are passed back to the business to demonstrate that IT will support the SLA and to build upon the trust between the two parties.
Correct Answer:
A. Identify all of the services currently delivered using the service catalogue. Define a primarily customer-based approach to implementing service levels agreements (SLAs). Using a pre-prepared pro-forma service level requirements (SLR) template, meet with the appropriate customer representatives to discuss and document their service level requirements. Arrange meetings with the appropriate IT teams, specifically those involved in incident, availability and capacity management, to discuss, document and agree the levels of service required. Draft agreements from these discussions are then reviewed by service operations to ensure that no existing agreements will be compromised and, once this has been confirmed, the SLA is formally reviewed, agreed, and signed by both the customer and IT. The service level targets are then formally communicated, monitored, reported upon and reviewed at the agreed intervals.
Explanation

This sequence represents the most effective and collaborative approach aligned with ITIL best practices for Service Level Management (SLM). It correctly begins by identifying services and then focuses on understanding the customer's needs by documenting Service Level Requirements (SLRs). Crucially, it then validates the feasibility of these requirements with internal IT teams before drafting and negotiating the final Service Level Agreement (SLA) with the customer. This ensures that the agreed-upon targets are both aligned with business needs and achievable by IT. The process concludes with the essential ongoing activities of monitoring, reporting, and reviewing, which are fundamental to the SLM lifecycle and rebuilding trust between IT and the business, as required by the scenario.

Why Incorrect

B: This option is fundamentally flawed because it completely omits the creation, negotiation, and signing of the Service Level Agreement (SLA), which is the central goal of the exercise. C: This option describes an IT-centric ("inside-out") approach, where IT dictates service levels. This would likely worsen the already strained relationship described in the scenario. D: This approach is high-risk as it agrees to an SLA with the business before confirming with internal teams that the targets are achievable, setting IT up for failure.

References

1. AXELOS, ITIL® Service Design (2011 ed.). The Stationery Office.

Section 4.3.5.2, "Service Level Requirements": This section emphasizes the importance of first capturing the business requirements in SLRs before creating an SLA. "All the service level targets for a new or changed service should be based on a set of SLRs." This supports the initial steps in option A.

Figure 4.9, "The SLM process": This diagram illustrates the correct flow: determine requirements -> produce draft SLAs/OLAs -> negotiate and agree on SLAs/OLAs -> review SLAs/OLAs and services. Option A is the only choice that correctly follows this logical sequence of negotiation and internal validation.

Section 4.3.5.4, "Operational Level Agreements": This section states, "In order to ensure that the service levels within the SLA can be delivered, it is important that the activities and responsibilities of the internal support groups are agreed." This confirms the necessity of consulting with IT teams before finalizing the SLA, as described in option A.

2. AXELOS, ITIL Foundation, ITIL 4 Edition (2019). The Stationery Office.

Section 5.2.14, "Service level management practice": This section describes the purpose of SLM as setting "clear business-based targets for service levels" and ensuring "that delivery of services is properly assessed, monitored, and managed against these targets." It emphasizes the need for a "shared view," which is achieved through the collaborative negotiation process outlined in option A, not the dictatorial approaches in C and D.

Keep practicing

Take the free ITIL-SOA practice test

Ten exam-style questions with answers and explanations, plus the exam facts and study guides.

Start the free practice test

More questions

Other ITIL-SOA practice questions

Scroll to Top