L5M2 practice question 22 of 25

An indemnity clause should contain which of the following pieces of information 1) duties of both parties 2) a monetary limit 3) insurance levels 4) details of the breach 5) a time limit

Full set: 115 questions
Answer options
A: 1,2,5 Correct answer
B: 1,3,4
C: 2,4,5
D: 3,4,5
Correct Answer:
A. 1,2,5
Explanation

A well-drafted indemnity clause is a critical risk management tool in a contract. To be effective and commercially viable, it should be precise and unambiguous. It must clearly define the duties of both parties (1), specifying the indemnifier's obligation to compensate and the indemnitee's duties, such as notifying of claims and mitigating losses. To manage financial exposure, it is standard practice to include a monetary limit (2) or cap on the total liability. Finally, a time limit (5) is essential to define the duration of the indemnity obligation, preventing indefinite or "long-tail" liability for the indemnifying party. These three elements are fundamental to creating a balanced and enforceable clause.

Why Incorrect

3) Insurance levels: This is incorrect because insurance requirements are typically detailed in a separate, dedicated insurance clause within the contract, not within the indemnity clause itself.
4) Details of the breach: This is incorrect as the clause is drafted before any breach occurs; it defines the types of events that trigger the indemnity, not the specific details of a future event.

References

1. CIPS. (2018). Managing Contractual Risk (L5M2). CIPS Profex Study Guide. Stamford

UK: Chartered Institute of Procurement & Supply. In the chapter on 'Key clauses in contracts'

the guide explains that effective indemnity clauses must be carefully drafted to specify the scope

triggers

financial caps (monetary limits)

and time limits to be commercially acceptable and manage risk effectively. It also covers the procedural aspects

which encompass the duties of the parties when a claim arises.

2. McKendrick

E. (2020). Contract Law: Text

Cases

and Materials. 9th ed. Oxford

UK: Oxford University Press. University-level legal texts on contract law emphasize that for certainty and enforceability

clauses that shift liability

such as indemnities

should clearly delineate the extent of the obligation

including any financial or temporal limitations

and the procedural steps (duties) for invoking the clause. (Relevant principles are discussed in chapters on contract terms and remedies for breach).

3. Schill

M. (2019). 'Boilerplate and the Bargaining Power of a Big Ego'. University of Chicago Law School

Coase-Sandor Institute for Law & Economics Research Paper No. 873. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3388811. Academic legal analysis of contractual clauses confirms that limitations on liability

including monetary caps and time limits

are standard and essential components of risk allocation clauses like indemnities

negotiated to reflect the parties' commercial agreement. (See discussion on Limitation of Liability clauses).

Scroll to Top