NEW-JERSEY-REAL-ESTATE-SALESPERSON practice question 24 of 25

A seller has entered into an exclusive right to sell agreement with a broker. The buyer presents the seller with an offer to purchase that is 20% less than the list price. Which of the following is appropriate?

Full set: 120 questions
Answer options
A: The seller is obligated to pay the buyer a commission or the offer price if the seller rejects the offer.
B: The seller is under no obligation to accept the offer or make a counteroffer. Correct answer
C: The seller has 72 hours to submit a counteroffer or else the offer is considered to be accepted.
D: The seller is obligated to make a counteroffer to the buyer if the offer is unacceptable.
Correct Answer:
B. The seller is under no obligation to accept the offer or make a counteroffer.
Explanation

In real estate transactions, a buyer's offer to purchase is a proposal, not a demand. The seller, as the offeree, retains complete discretion over how to respond. The seller is not legally compelled to accept any offer, regardless of its price, nor are they required to engage in negotiations by making a counteroffer. The seller can accept the offer, reject it outright, or propose a counteroffer. The decision rests solely with the seller, and inaction or explicit rejection terminates the buyer's offer without any further obligation on the seller's part.

Why Incorrect

A. A seller's commission is owed to their broker, never to a buyer. Rejecting an offer does not create any financial liability from the seller to the buyer.
C. There is no universal or legally mandated 72-hour response period. Any time limit for acceptance is set by the buyer in the offer itself; silence implies rejection, not acceptance.
D. A seller is never obligated to make a counteroffer. A counteroffer is a tool for negotiation, which the seller may choose to use or not at their sole discretion.

References

1. New Jersey Administrative Code, Title 11, Chapter 5 (New Jersey Real Estate Commission), N.J.A.C. 11:5-6.4(a): This regulation mandates that a licensee must transmit all written offers on a property to their principal (the seller) within 24 hours of receipt. This rule establishes the agent's duty to present offers but implicitly confirms the seller's position as the ultimate decision-maker who can accept or reject said offers. The regulation does not impose any obligation on the seller to act upon the offer.

2. Jennings, M. M. (2017). Real Estate Law (11th ed.). Cengage Learning. In Chapter 9, "The Sales Contract," the fundamental principles of contract formation are discussed. It is established that for a contract to be valid, there must be an offer and acceptance. The offeree (seller) has the power to accept, reject, or make a counteroffer, which is a rejection of the original offer. There is no legal duty for the offeree to accept or counter. (See pages 230-232 on "The Offer" and "Acceptance").

3. Galaty, F. W., Allaway, W. J., & Kyle, R. C. (2022). Modern Real Estate Practice (21st ed.). DF Institute, Inc. Chapter 11, "Real Estate Contracts," explains that an offer is not a binding contract until it is accepted by the offeree without any changes. The seller "is not obligated to accept it or even to make a counteroffer." The seller's only response options are to accept, reject, or counteroffer. (See section on "Offer and Acceptance").

Scroll to Top