NPPE practice question 22 of 25

Susan, a professional member, is hired to conduct an environmental site assessment that includes inspection of a commercial building and property and…

Full set: 111 questions
Susan, a professional member, is hired to conduct an environmental site assessment that includes inspection of a commercial building and property and identification of potential environmental hazards. The client is anxious to complete the assessment quickly to accommodate a property sale. The site is adjacent to an elementary school, inspection occurs in winter with snow cover, access to one storeroom is unavailable, and strong gasoline vapours are detected in the basement. Of the following decisions, which would be the most ethical one for Susan to make?
Answer options
A: Refuse to submit the report.
B: Consider her employer's interest as most important, and approve and send the report.
C: Ask the client to have the area cleaned and provide access to the storeroom, then conduct a thorough inspection and submit the report. Correct answer
D: Wait until summer when snow-free inspection and storeroom access are possible before completing the report.
Correct Answer:
C. Ask the client to have the area cleaned and provide access to the storeroom, then conduct a thorough inspection and submit the report.
Explanation

The most ethical decision upholds the professional's paramount duty to public safety and the duty to act with competence and integrity. The presence of gasoline vapours near a school is a significant public safety risk. Limitations like snow cover and an inaccessible room prevent a thorough, competent assessment. Option C directly addresses these issues by requiring the client to enable a complete inspection. This allows the professional to fulfill their duties to the client, the public, and the profession by providing a comprehensive and accurate report based on sufficient data, rather than refusing the work or submitting an incomplete or misleading assessment.

Why Incorrect

A. Refusing to submit the report is a premature and unconstructive step; the duty is to find a way to complete the work competently.
B. The professional's duty to public safety is paramount and overrides the employer's or client's interest in a quick, potentially flawed, report.
D. Waiting until summer is an unnecessarily long delay; the immediate hazards (vapours, locked room) can and should be addressed promptly.

References

1. Andrews, G. C. (2019). Canadian Professional Engineering and Geoscience: Practice and Ethics (6th ed.). Nelson.

Chapter 2, Section 2.2.1 "The Primacy of Public Welfare," emphasizes that the duty to the public is paramount.

Chapter 21, Section 21.3 "Competence and Negligence," discusses the requirement to have adequate knowledge and perform work thoroughly.

2. Association of Professional Engineers and Geoscientists of Saskatchewan (APEGS). (2020). The Engineering and Geoscience Professions Act and Bylaws.

Bylaw 14(2)(b) states a member shall "undertake only such work as they are competent to perform by virtue of their training and experience."

Scroll to Top