NPPE practice question 14 of 25

Which of the following situations is an example of indirect discrimination in the workplace?

Full set: 111 questions
Answer options
A: Company A seldom promotes female geoscientists to management positions despite their qualifications.
B: The CEO of Company B makes offensive jokes and remarks about men, but only to female employees during lunch hour.
C: Company C hires only people with a clean and valid driver's licence, even though driving is not part of the job description. Correct answer
D: An engineer from a visible minority is not promoted to senior management in Company D despite being well qualified.
Correct Answer:
C. Company C hires only people with a clean and valid driver's licence, even though driving is not part of the job description.
Explanation

Indirect discrimination, also known as adverse effect discrimination, occurs when a seemingly neutral policy or practice has a disproportionately negative impact on a group protected by human rights legislation. The requirement for a driver's license for a non-driving job is a classic example. While the rule applies to everyone, it can unfairly exclude individuals with certain disabilities or from low-income backgrounds who are less likely to have a license. Since driving is not a bona fide occupational requirement (BFOR), the policy is discriminatory.

Why Incorrect

A. This describes systemic or direct discrimination, as it points to a pattern of treating a protected group (women) unfavourably.
B. This is an example of workplace harassment, which is a form of direct discrimination, not indirect.
D. This is a case of direct discrimination, where an individual is treated differently based on their membership in a protected group.

References

1. Andrews, G.C. (2019). Canadian Professional Engineering and Geoscience: Practice and Ethics, 6th Edition. Chapter 10, "Human Rights and Employment Equity," pp. 218-219. The text defines and provides examples of indirect (adverse effect) discrimination.

2. Canadian Human Rights Commission. (n.d.). What is Discrimination? Retrieved from the official CHRC website. The commission defines adverse effect discrimination as a rule that seems neutral but has a negative impact on a protected group.

Scroll to Top