PDPF practice question 21 of 25

The GDPR refers to the principles of proportionality and subsidiarity. What is the meaning of subsidiarity in this context?

Full set: 149 questions
Answer options
A: Personal data may only be processed when there are no other means to achieve the purposes. Correct answer
B: Personal data cannot be reused without explicit and informed consent.
C: Personal data can only be processed in accordance with the purpose specification.
D: Personal data must be adequate, relevant and not excessive in relation to the purposes.
Correct Answer:
A. Personal data may only be processed when there are no other means to achieve the purposes.
Explanation

In the context of EU law and the GDPR, subsidiarity is a component of the broader principle of proportionality. The proportionality principle requires that any interference with the fundamental right to data protection must be justified. This justification involves a three-part test: suitability, necessity, and balancing. Subsidiarity falls under the necessity test. It dictates that processing personal data should be a measure of last resort. If a legitimate purpose can be achieved through other, less intrusive means that do not involve processing personal data, then those means must be chosen. Therefore, processing is only permissible when no other viable alternatives exist.

Why Incorrect

B. This statement describes a specific aspect of the purpose limitation principle and the conditions for valid consent, not the principle of subsidiarity.
C. This is the definition of the purpose limitation principle (Article 5(1)(b) GDPR), which ensures data is only used for the reasons it was collected.
D. This is the definition of the data minimisation principle (Article 5(1)(c) GDPR), which is also part of proportionality but is distinct from subsidiarity.

References

1. European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) Glossary. The EDPS defines the proportionality principle as follows: "The necessity of a measure is evaluated by assessing whether another, less intrusive measure could be used to achieve the same objective (subsidiarity)." This directly links subsidiarity to the concept of using less intrusive means.

Source: European Data Protection Supervisor, "Glossary," section on "Proportionality principle." Available at the official EDPS website.

2. Kranenborg, H. (2017). Proportionality in the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union on the Data Protection Directive. This academic analysis of CJEU case law explains that the necessity test, a core part of proportionality, "implies that where there is a choice between several appropriate measures, the least onerous one must be adopted. This is also referred to as the principle of subsidiarity."

Source: Kranenborg, H. (2017). Proportionality in the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union on the Data Protection Directive. Utrecht Journal of International and European Law, 33(85), pp. 45-58. (Specifically, Section 3.2 "Necessity"). DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/ujiel.401

3. Article 29 Working Party (WP29), Opinion 06/2014 on the notion of legitimate interests of the data controller under Article 7 of Directive 95/46/EC. While pre-dating the GDPR, the principles are foundational. The opinion details the balancing test for legitimate interests, which includes an assessment of necessity. It states the processing must be "the least intrusive means of processing to achieve the pursued interest." This embodies the subsidiarity concept.

Source: WP29, Opinion 06/2014, WP 217, adopted on 9 April 2014, p. 29.

Scroll to Top