QSA_NEW_V4 practice question 4 of 10

An entity wants to use the Customized Approach. They are unsure how to complete the Controls Matrix or TR

Full set: 40 questions
Answer options
A: During the assessment, you spend time completing the Controls Matrix and the TRA, while also ensuring that the customized control is implemented securely. Which of the following statements is true?
B: You can assess the customized control, but another assessor must verify that you completed the TRA correctly.
C: You can assess the customized control and verify that the customized approach was correctly followed, but you must document this in the ROC.
D: You must document the work on the customized control in the ROC, but you can not assess the control or the documentation. Correct answer
E: Assessors are not allowed to assist an entity with the completion of the Controls Matrix or the TRA.
Correct Answer:
D. You must document the work on the customized control in the ROC, but you can not assess the control or the documentation.
Explanation

Analysis

The question addresses the role of QSAs when entities use PCI DSS v4.0's Customized Approach, specifically regarding assistance with the Controls Matrix and Targeted Risk Analysis (TRA), and the assessment of customized controls.

Under PCI DSS v4.0, the Customized Approach allows entities to implement alternative controls that meet the security objective differently than prescribed requirements. The key issue is understanding QSA independence requirements and permitted activities.

Correct Answer: D

Explanation:

QSAs must maintain independence and cannot assist entities in developing their compliance approach or completing required documentation. The Controls Matrix and TRA are entity responsibilities that form the basis for the Customized Approach. While QSAs assess the adequacy of completed documentation and implemented controls, they cannot participate in creating these materials. This maintains the separation between implementation (entity responsibility) and validation (assessor responsibility), ensuring objective assessment.

Why Incorrect Options are Wrong:

A: Incorrect - QSAs cannot complete the TRA; this violates independence requirements.

B: Incorrect - QSAs cannot complete Controls Matrix/TRA; they only assess completed work.

C: Incorrect - QSAs can and must assess customized controls and documentation.

References:

1. PCI DSS v4.0 Requirements and Testing Procedures, Section 12.3.2 (Customized Approach methodology)
2. PCI SSC QSA Qualification Requirements v4.0, Section 3.2 (Independence requirements)
3. PCI DSS v4.0 Report on Compliance Template, Appendix D (Customized Approach documentation requirements)
4. PCI SSC Customized Approach Guidance, Section 2.3 (Roles and responsibilities)
5. ISO 19011:2018 Guidelines for auditing management systems, Section 4.4 (Auditor independence principles)

Why Incorrect

A. Independence is still violated even if a second assessor reviews your work.
B. Performing both preparation and assessment breaks independence; merely documenting it in the ROC does not resolve the conflict.
C. You may assess the control, but only if you did not prepare the documentation; the statement misrepresents assessor obligations.

References

1. PCI Security Standards Council. QSA Qualification Requirements v5.0 (2022), §2.2 “Independence,” pp. 9-10.

2. PCI Security Standards Council. PCI DSS v4.0, “Customized Approach” overview, pp. 36-38.

3. PCI Security Standards Council. PCI DSS v4.0 ROC Reporting Instructions, §2.1, p. 6.

Scroll to Top