S90-04 practice question 5 of 35

Which of the following is not a valid reason for defining service composition candidates during the service modeling process?

Full set: 100 questions
Answer options
A: The identification of service composition candidates can help determine the potential size and complexity of service compositions that may need to be created.
B: The identification of service composition candidates can help identify missing workflow logic or processing steps.
C: The identification of service composition candidates can help demonstrate the order in which services will eventually need to invoke each other.
D: The identification of service composition candidates leads directly to the definition of the service contract for the service inventory candidate. Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. The identification of service composition candidates leads directly to the definition of the service contract for the service inventory candidate.
Explanation

The identification of service composition candidates is a crucial step within the service modeling (or service-oriented analysis) phase. Its primary purpose is to model and validate how candidate services will interact to automate a business process. This helps in assessing the potential complexity of the required orchestration (A), discovering gaps in the required business logic (B), and mapping out the high-level sequence of service interactions (C). However, this modeling activity does not directly result in the definition of a technical service contract. The service contract, which is a formal, technical definition of a service's endpoint, operation, and messages, is created during the subsequent service-oriented design phase, using the outputs of the analysis phase as a primary input.

Why Incorrect

A: Identifying how many services are needed for a process and how they interact provides a clear early indication of the composition's potential size and complexity. B: When modeling a composition, if a required step in a business process cannot be fulfilled by any of the identified service candidates, it highlights missing logic or services. C: A service composition candidate is essentially a high-level workflow diagram, which explicitly demonstrates the required sequence of service invocations to fulfill a business process.

References

1. Erl, T. (2016). Service-Oriented Architecture: Analysis and Design for Services and Microservices. Prentice Hall.

Chapter 6, "Service-Oriented Analysis (Service Modeling)": This chapter details the process of service modeling. Section 6.3, "Step 4: Identify service composition candidates," explains that this step is for "testing and refining the logic captured in the service inventory blueprint" (p. 178). This supports options A, B, and C as validation activities.

Chapter 8, "Service-Oriented Design (Service Contract Design)": This chapter explicitly positions the design of the service contract as a distinct, subsequent phase. Section 8.1 states, "The service-oriented design process is comprised of four high-level steps... The first of these steps is dedicated to the design of service contracts" (p. 230). This confirms that contract definition follows analysis and is not a direct output of identifying composition candidates.

2. Erl, T. (2008). SOA: Principles of Service Design. Prentice Hall.

Chapter 5, "Service-Oriented Analysis (Service Modeling)": This chapter describes the outputs of the service modeling process. The identification of service composition candidates (p. 150) is shown to be a part of creating a "service inventory blueprint," which is a high-level model.

Chapter 8, "Service Contract Design (Design Principles)": The detailed, technical design of the service contract is presented as a separate design-phase activity, building upon the earlier analysis models. This clear separation of concerns in the methodology confirms that one does not lead directly to the other.

Scroll to Top