S90-08 practice question 13 of 35

For a given service inventory architecture you would choose between an enterprise service bus product or an orchestration product, but you would not use both together.

Full set: 100 questions
Answer options
A:

A. True

B:

B. False

Correct Answer:
FALSE
Explanation

The statement is incorrect because an Enterprise Service Bus (ESB) and an orchestration engine fulfill distinct and complementary roles within a service inventory architecture. An ESB provides a messaging and integration backbone, focusing on routing, protocol transformation, and mediation between services. An orchestration engine, on the other hand, is a specialized component for executing business process logic by coordinating and composing multiple services into a single, stateful, long-running transaction. It is a common and valid architectural pattern to deploy an orchestration engine that leverages the underlying ESB for communication and connectivity with the services it is orchestrating.

Why Incorrect

The "True" option is incorrect as it presents a false choice. These two technologies are not mutually exclusive. The ESB handles the "how" of communication (the plumbing), while orchestration handles the "what" and "when" of business logic execution (the process). Many enterprise architectures use them together to achieve both robust integration and complex process automation.

References

1. Erl, T. (2005). Service-Oriented Architecture: Concepts, Technology, and Design. Prentice Hall.

Chapter 16: Common SOA-Related Technologies: This chapter describes orchestration and ESBs as separate but related technologies. Section 16.3 on Orchestration explains its role in executing process logic (e.g., using BPEL), while Section 16.4 on the Enterprise Service Bus describes its function as an intermediary for message processing and routing. The text implicitly supports their coexistence by defining their separate, non-overlapping primary functions. For example, on page 528, the book states, "Orchestration... centralizes the coordination of services for a specific business process," while on page 535, it describes the ESB as providing "a range of message processing and routing features." These distinct roles highlight their complementary nature.

2. Erl, T. (2008). SOA: Principles of Service Design. Prentice Hall.

Chapter 17: Composition in Action: This chapter provides examples of service composition. Figure 17.18, for instance, illustrates a process service that composes other services. The implementation of such a process service would typically be hosted within an orchestration engine, which in turn would communicate with the other services via the underlying messaging infrastructure, often an ESB. The book establishes orchestration as the means of implementing process logic and the messaging layer (ESB) as the communication medium, reinforcing that they work together.

Scroll to Top