S90-19 practice question 8 of 15
The use of derived keys is based on symmetric encryption. This is similar to asymmetric encryption because different keys can be derived from a session key and used separately for encryption and decryption.
Full set: 83 questionsThe statement is false because its reasoning creates an incorrect analogy between key derivation in symmetric cryptography and the fundamental principle of asymmetric cryptography. While the first part of the statement is correct—key derivation is commonly used in symmetric encryption systems to generate session keys from a master key—the second part is incorrect. The defining characteristic of asymmetric encryption is the use of a mathematically linked but distinct key pair: a public key to encrypt data and a private key to decrypt it. In a symmetric system using derived keys, even if multiple keys are derived (e.g., one for encryption, another for message authentication), the key used to encrypt a piece of data is the same key used to decrypt that same data. The principle remains symmetric. The statement incorrectly suggests that deriving different keys for separate functions is equivalent to the public/private key mechanism.
The statement is not "True" because the justification provided is fundamentally flawed. The ability to derive multiple keys from a single secret source does not make the cryptographic system "similar to asymmetric encryption." The core operational difference—a single shared key for encryption/decryption (symmetric) versus a public/private key pair (asymmetric)—remains.
1. NIST Special Publication 800-57 Part 1 Revision 5, "Recommendation for Key Management":
Section 2.1.1, "Symmetric-key and Asymmetric-key Cryptography": This section explicitly defines the two types of cryptography. It states, "In symmetric-key cryptography (also called secret-key cryptography), the same key (the secret key) is used for both the cryptographic protection... and the removal of that protection." For asymmetric-key cryptography, it states, "two related keys are required: a public key and a private key. The public key may be known by anyone; the private key is held only by its owner... a private key is used to decrypt data that has been encrypted with the corresponding public key." This highlights the fundamental difference that the question misrepresents.
2. NIST Special Publication 800-108r1, "Recommendation for Key Derivation Using Pseudorandom Functions":
Section 1, "Introduction": This document describes key derivation as a process where "one or more secret keys are derived from a secret value... using a pseudorandom function." The derived keys are then used in other cryptographic algorithms, which are typically symmetric ciphers or message authentication codes (MACs), reinforcing that the context is symmetric cryptography, not a hybrid that mimics asymmetric principles.
3. Stallings, W. (2017). Cryptography and Network Security: Principles and Practice (7th ed.):
Chapter 2, "Classical Encryption Techniques": Section 2.1 defines symmetric encryption as involving a single key shared by the sender and receiver. Section 2.2 introduces asymmetric encryption, emphasizing the use of two separate keys (public and private) and stating, "It is computationally infeasible to determine the decryption key given only the cryptographic algorithm and the encryption key." The book treats these as distinct paradigms, and the process of deriving multiple symmetric keys does not alter this fundamental distinction.
Keep practicing
Take the free S90-19 practice test
Ten exam-style questions with answers and explanations, plus the exam facts and study guides.
More questions
Other S90-19 practice questions
- Question 1A service is designed to respond to an error condition by issuing a message containing de…
- Question 2Because of a new security requirement, all messages received by Service A need to be logg…
- Question 3Service A contains reporting logic that collects statistical data from different sources …
- Question 4The application of the Message Screening pattern can help avoid which of the following at…
- Question 5The Exception Shielding pattern can be applied together with the Trusted Subsystem patter…
- Question 6Which of the following types of attack always affect the availability of a service?
