S90-19 practice question 13 of 15

Which of the following types of WS-SecurityPolicy assertions is required in order to determine whether derived keys are needed for a key agreement security session?

Full set: 83 questions
Answer options
A: protection assertions
B: token assertions
C: security binding assertions Correct answer
D: None of the above.
Correct Answer:
C. security binding assertions
Explanation

Security binding assertions, such as sp:SymmetricBinding or sp:AsymmetricBinding, define the fundamental mechanism for how security tokens are used to protect messages. The sp:RequireDerivedKeys assertion, which mandates the use of derived keys from a shared secret for a security session, is specified as a potential child element of the security binding assertion within the WS-SecurityPolicy framework. Therefore, the security binding assertion is the primary and overarching policy element that must be inspected to determine if derived keys are required for the security context. It orchestrates the entire security mechanism, including the key derivation strategy.

Why Incorrect

A. protection assertions: These assertions specify what parts of a message to protect (e.g., which headers to sign or encrypt), not the cryptographic methods used for protection.
B. token assertions: While a sp:SecureConversationToken assertion (a token assertion) can contain a nested policy with sp:RequireDerivedKeys, the binding assertion can also contain it directly and is the mandatory, top-level element that defines the entire security mechanism.
D. None of the above: This is incorrect because security binding assertions are the correct type for this determination. ---

References

1. OASIS Standard, "WS-SecurityPolicy 1.2", 01 July 2007.

Section 6, "Security Binding Assertions": This section introduces binding assertions as the policies that "define how security is applied to a message."

Section 7.1, "RequireDerivedKeys Assertion": This section explicitly states, "This assertion applies to sp:SymmetricBinding, sp:AsymmetricBinding and sp:SecureConversationToken assertions." This confirms that the requirement can be specified directly within the binding, making the binding assertion the necessary element to check.

2. Erl, T., et al. (2012). SOA Security: Advanced Security for Service-Oriented Architectures. Prentice Hall.

Chapter 11, WS-Policy, Page 378: The text states, "This assertion [sp:RequireDerivedKeys] can be placed inside a security binding assertion (such as the SymmetricBinding assertion or the AsymmetricBinding assertion) to indicate that derived keys must be used for creating signatures and for performing encryption." This directly supports that the binding assertion is the correct location for this policy.

Scroll to Top