Virginia-Life-Annuities-and-Health-Insurance practice question 21 of 35

When an HIV test is requested by a health insurer, who signs the consent form?

Full set: 440 questions

Domain Virginia Laws and Regulations

Answer options
A: The applicant Correct answer
B: The applicant’s physician
C: The insurance agent
D: The medical laboratory technician
Correct Answer:
A. The applicant
Explanation

Virginia law mandates the principle of informed consent for medical testing in the context of insurance underwriting. When a health insurer requires an HIV test as part of the application process, the insurer must first obtain specific, written, and informed consent from the individual to be tested. This legal requirement ensures that the applicant understands the nature of the test, the reasons for it, and how the results will be used. The signature of the applicant on the consent form serves as legal proof that this consent was given voluntarily.

Why Incorrect

B. The applicant’s physician: The physician administers medical care but cannot legally provide consent on behalf of a competent adult applicant for an insurer's underwriting purposes.
C. The insurance agent: The agent is a representative of the insurer and has a clear conflict of interest; they have no legal authority to consent for the applicant.
D. The medical laboratory technician: The technician's role is to perform the test accurately; they have no legal standing to provide consent for the person being tested. ---

References

1. Code of Virginia, Title 38.2. Insurance, § 38.2-613. Testing for HIV.

Section A states: "No insurer shall test any person for the presence of the causative agent for acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) without first obtaining the written informed consent of such person." This statute explicitly places the responsibility of consent on the person being tested, who is the applicant.

2. Virginia State Corporation Commission, Bureau of Insurance, Administrative Letter 1989-11, "Testing for Exposure to the Human Immunodeficiency Virus."

Section II. Informed Consent, Paragraph A: This administrative letter provides guidance to all licensed insurance companies, stating, "Before any applicant can be tested for HIV, the applicant must give his or her written informed consent for the test." It further details the required elements of the consent form that the applicant must sign.

3. Center for Health & Bioethics, University of Virginia School of Medicine. "Informed Consent in Clinical Practice."

This university resource outlines the core ethical and legal principles of informed consent, emphasizing that consent must be obtained directly from the patient or subject of a procedure. In the insurance context, the applicant is the subject, and therefore, their direct consent is non-negotiable.

Scroll to Top