AICP practice question 19 of 25

A local planner, an AICP member, participates on the site selection committee for a new reservoir. As a member of this committee, the planner must review draft technical reports. On the planner’s own time, the planner is a member of the board of directors of a conservation society, which generally opposes facilities that encourage growth. In this situation, the planner should first:

Full set: 170 questions
Answer options
A: Resign from the society board.
B: Abstain from any society board votes on the reservoir.
C: Inform the city planning director of involvement with the society. Correct answer
D: Participate in the society’s decision-making process.
Correct Answer:
C. Inform the city planning director of involvement with the society.
Explanation

The AICP Code of Ethics requires planners to address any actual, potential, or even perceived conflicts of interest. The planner's dual roles—serving a public agency on a project and serving on the board of an organization that may oppose that project—create a clear potential conflict. The first and most critical step is to provide full written disclosure of the outside involvement to the primary client or employer (in this case, the city planning director). This allows the employer to be aware of the situation and determine the appropriate course of action.

Why Incorrect

A. Resigning from the board is a possible remedy, but it is not the required first step; disclosure must happen first.
B. Abstaining from votes is a necessary action to manage the conflict, but it should follow disclosure to the primary employer.
D. Actively participating in the society's decision-making on this issue would be a direct and unmanaged conflict of interest, violating ethical duties.

References

1. American Institute of Certified Planners. (2016). AICP Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct. American Planning Association. Rules of Conduct, Rule #3 states, "We shall not accept an assignment from a client or employer when the services to be performed involve a conflict of interest, or even the appearance of a conflict of interest, unless we have made full written disclosure to the client or employer..."

2. Barrett, C. D. (2012). Everyday Ethics for Practicing Planners. American Planning Association. Chapter 3, "Conflicts of Interest," emphasizes that disclosure to the client or employer is the foundational step in ethically managing any conflict.

3. Wachs, M. (Ed.). (1985). Ethics in Planning. Center for Urban Policy Research, Rutgers University. This foundational text discusses the planner's primary obligation to their client/employer and the imperative to disclose any divided loyalties (pp. 121-125).

Scroll to Top