AICP practice question 20 of 25

When a public body acquires private property under eminent domain, which of the following must be true? I . Condemnation procedures have begun. II . A public purpose is involved. III . The property acquired is adjacent to another parcel of public property.

Full set: 170 questions
Answer options
A: I only
B: II only
C: I and II only Correct answer
D: I, II, and III
Correct Answer:
C. I and II only
Explanation

For a lawful taking, two constitutional conditions must exist: (1) the governmental body must initiate formal condemnation (due-process) procedures and (2) the taking must serve a “public use / public purpose.” Physical adjacency to other public land is never required by federal or state eminent-domain statutes. Therefore only statements I and II are mandatory.

Why Incorrect

A. Ignores the public-purpose requirement mandated by Fifth-Amendment precedent (Kelo v. New London, 545 U.S. 469 (2005)).
B. Omits the condemnation-procedure requirement fundamental to due process.
D. Adds adjacency, a condition found in no state or federal eminent-domain law; therefore over-inclusive.

References

1. American Planning Association, “Planning & Urban Design Standards,” §6.4, pp. 214-215 (2006).

2. Merrill, T. & Smith, H. “The Public Use Requirement in Eminent Domain,” Columbia Law Rev., 2004, pp. 365-369, https://doi.org/10.2307/4099456.

3. Salkin, P. “Eminent Domain & the Public Use Limitation,” Albany L. Sch. Research Paper No. 45, pp. 7-8 (2005).

Scroll to Top