AICP practice question 15 of 25

A planner is asked to assist a social service agency in analyzing a survey it conducted. The survey results will be used to identify needs and prioritize funding. In preparing the analysis, the planner discovers that the reliability of some of the data is questionable. In this situation, the planner should first:

Full set: 170 questions
Answer options
A: Refuse to continue with the project until the data are corrected
B: Rely on other sources of data and continue with the project
C: Evaluate the seriousness of the problem and report it to the project leader Correct answer
D: Write the findings of the survey as reported, noting the reliability problem
Correct Answer:
C. Evaluate the seriousness of the problem and report it to the project leader
Explanation

The planner's primary responsibility is to ensure the integrity and accuracy of their work. Upon discovering questionable data, the first professional step is to assess the extent and potential impact of the problem and then immediately inform the client or project leader. This aligns with the AICP Code of Ethics, which mandates honesty and the provision of accurate information. This course of action allows for a collaborative decision on how to proceed, which might involve data correction, using alternative data, or qualifying the results. Acting unilaterally is unprofessional and could lead to flawed conclusions.

Why Incorrect

A. Refusing to continue is an extreme measure that should only be considered after evaluation and discussion with the project leader fail to resolve the ethical issue.
B. Relying on other data without first reporting the issue with the primary data source is irresponsible and avoids addressing the core problem.
D. Writing the findings while noting the problem is a later step; the immediate ethical obligation is to report the issue to the decision-makers.

References

1. American Institute of Certified Planners. (2022). AICP Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct. Section A, "Principles to Which We Aspire," Principle 1.a: "We shall always be conscious of the rights of others." and Section B, "Our Rules of Conduct," Rule 2: "We shall not accept an assignment from a client or employer when the services to be performed involve conduct that we know to be illegal or in violation of these rules." and Rule 5: "We shall not, as public officials or employees, accept from anyone other than our public employer any compensation, commission, rebate, or other advantage that may be perceived as related to our public office or employment." While not a direct quote, the spirit of the code is to act with integrity and honesty, which requires reporting data issues. The most relevant is the overall principle of providing accurate information.

2. American Planning Association. (2005). Ethical Principles in Planning. "A planner must strive to provide full, clear and accurate information on planning issues to citizens and governmental decision-makers." This principle underpins the need to address data reliability issues upfront.

Scroll to Top