AICP practice question 16 of 25

Which type of analysis uses the average cost method and/or the case study marginal approach?

Full set: 170 questions
Answer options
A: Fiscal impact Correct answer
B: Economic impact
C: Multi-variate statistical
D: Development pro-forma
Correct Answer:
A. Fiscal impact
Explanation

Fiscal impact analysis (FIA) is a methodology used to project the net financial effect of a new development on a local government. The core of an FIA is calculating the additional public service costs and revenues generated by the project. The "average cost method" (or per capita multiplier method) and the "case study marginal approach" are two of the primary, well-established techniques for estimating these costs. The average cost method applies a jurisdiction's average per-capita cost of services to the new population, while the marginal approach calculates the specific additional costs the new development will actually create.

Why Incorrect

B. Economic impact analysis measures broader effects on the regional economy (jobs, income, output) using tools like input-output models, not these specific costing methods.
C. Multi-variate statistical analysis is a broad category of advanced statistical methods (e.g., regression) and not a specific type of planning analysis defined by these two approaches.
D. A development pro-forma is a financial statement from the developer's perspective, analyzing the profitability of a project, not its impact on public finances.

References

1. Burchell, R. W., & Listokin, D. (1978). The Fiscal Impact Handbook: Estimating Local Costs and Revenues of Land Development. Center for Urban Policy Research, Rutgers University. This is the foundational text that extensively details the average cost (per capita) and case study (marginal) methods as central to FIA. (See Chapters 2 and 3).

2. American Planning Association. (2003). PAS Report 515: Fiscal Impact Analysis: A Primer for Planners. This report explicitly describes the "average cost (per capita multiplier) approach" and the "case study (marginal cost) approach" as the two main methodologies for conducting fiscal impact analysis.

3. Tischler, P. S. (1988). The NAIOP guide to fiscal impact analysis. National Association of Industrial and Office Parks. This guide for practitioners also outlines these standard methodologies for assessing the fiscal impacts of development on local governments.

Scroll to Top