AICP practice question 17 of 25

Which of these metropolitan regions have appointed or elected regional governance systems that bridge city-suburb boundaries and manage transit, parks and recreation, affordable housing, wastewater, or urban growth boundaries? I . Minneapolis/St. Paul, Minnesota II . Orlando, Florida III . Portland, Oregon IV . Phoenix, Arizona

Full set: 170 questions
Answer options
A: I and II
B: I and III Correct answer
C: II and IV
D: III and IV
Correct Answer:
B. I and III
Explanation

The Minneapolis/St. Paul and Portland metropolitan regions are two of the most frequently cited examples of robust regional governance in the United States. The Metropolitan Council in the Twin Cities is an appointed body with significant authority over regional planning, wastewater services, and transit. Portland's Metro is unique as the nation's only directly elected regional government, managing the urban growth boundary, solid waste, regional parks, and other services that cross city and county lines. Both entities possess the operational and planning authority described in the question.

Why Incorrect

A. Orlando's regional planning council is primarily an advisory and coordinating body without the direct operational authority of the Met Council or Metro.
C. Phoenix and Orlando both have Councils of Governments (COGs) that facilitate inter-jurisdictional cooperation but do not function as a formal layer of regional government.
D. The Maricopa Association of Governments (MAG) in Phoenix is a COG focused on transportation planning and coordination, not a comprehensive regional governance system.

References

1. Orfield, M. (1997). Metropolitics: A Regional Agenda for Community and Stability. Brookings Institution Press. Chapter 4 details the structure and authority of the Minneapolis-St. Paul Metropolitan Council.

2. Abbott, C. (2012). Portland in Three Centuries: The Place and the People. Oregon State University Press. Chapter 7 discusses the creation and functions of Portland's Metro government and its role in managing the Urban Growth Boundary.

3. Norris, D. F. (2001). Whither regional governance? Journal of Urban Affairs, 23(5), 531-551. https://doi.org/10.1111/0735-2166.00101. This article contrasts the strong models of Portland and Minneapolis-St. Paul with the more common, weaker council-of-governments model found elsewhere.

Scroll to Top