CIMAPRA19-E02-1 practice question 2 of 30

H is the owner of a motorcycle dealership in Los Angeles which provides sales, repair and servicing of very large motorcycles, typically with engines…

Full set: 210 questions
H is the owner of a motorcycle dealership in Los Angeles which provides sales, repair and servicing of very large motorcycles, typically with engines larger than 1000cc. Over the years H has built up a renowned team of highly skilled technicians that are experts in this particular size of motorcycle. H believes that their skills are rare and difficult, if not impossible, to imitate by any competitor in the region. Despite this advantage the company has been suffering from declining profits in the past three years and the marketing consultant has advised H to change the focus of the company towards small 50cc mopeds and scooters - because that "is clearly what the market is now wanting". The change being proposed is:
Answer options
A: from a resource-based view to a positioning approach. Correct answer
B: from a resource-based view to an incremental approach.
C: from a positioning approach to a 'market driven' strategy.
D: from a positioning approach to a rational model.
Correct Answer:
A. from a resource-based view to a positioning approach.
Explanation

The company's current strategy is based on its unique internal capabilities—a "renowned team of highly skilled technicians" whose skills are "rare and difficult... to imitate." This is the essence of the resource-based view (RBV) of strategy, which argues that competitive advantage comes from valuable, rare, inimitable, and non-substitutable (VRIN) internal resources. The consultant's advice to shift focus to what "the market is now wanting" (small mopeds) represents a move towards an outside-in, market-driven strategy. This is best described as a positioning approach, where strategy is determined by analysing the external environment and positioning the firm to serve market needs.

Why Incorrect

B. from a resource-based view to an incremental approach. Incrementalism describes the process of strategy formation (small, emergent changes), not the strategic content (internal resources vs. external market).
C. from a positioning approach to a 'market driven' strategy. A positioning approach is a type of market-driven strategy; this option does not describe a change in approach.
D. from a positioning approach to a rational model. The rational model is a formal process for developing strategy, not a strategic perspective like the positioning or resource-based view.

References

1. Barney, J. (1991). Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99-120. https://doi.org/10.1177/014920639101700108. This paper is the foundation of the Resource-Based View (RBV), defining competitive advantage through internal firm attributes.

2. Porter, M. E. (1980). Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors. Free Press. This book establishes the positioning school, where strategy is about choosing an attractive industry and positioning the firm favourably within it.

3. Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (CIMA). (2019). E2 Managing Performance - Official Study Text. Chapter 1: The strategy process, Section 2 'Perspectives on strategy'. This chapter contrasts the positioning view (outside-in) with the resource-based view (inside-out).

Scroll to Top