CIMAPRA19-E02-1 practice question 6 of 30

X is a manufacturing company that has achieved long term success by understanding the structure of its industry, and where necessary changing its…

Full set: 210 questions
X is a manufacturing company that has achieved long term success by understanding the structure of its industry, and where necessary changing its strategy in order to achieve improved performance by outperforming its competitors. Success has depended on the company exploiting the underlying economic factors (such as economies of scale) better than its competitors and maintaining this over time, so achieving sustainable competitive advantage. Researchers would call this an "outside-in" approach to strategy, with the company choosing a strategy that responds to the challenges and changes posed by the external environment. Which type of strategy is X adopting?
Answer options
A: Positioning approach Correct answer
B: Resource-based view
C: Emergent strategy development
D: Logical incrementalism
Correct Answer:
A. Positioning approach
Explanation

The "outside-in" approach described is the essence of the Positioning school of strategy, most famously associated with Michael Porter. This perspective posits that a firm's performance is primarily determined by its industry structure and its strategic position within that industry. The company analyzes the external environment (e.g., using Porter's Five Forces) to choose a defensible position (e.g., cost leadership, differentiation) and then aligns its internal activities to support that position, thereby outperforming rivals.

Why Incorrect

B. The resource-based view is an "inside-out" approach, arguing that competitive advantage stems from unique internal resources and capabilities, not the external environment.
C. Emergent strategy arises from unplanned actions and patterns over time, contrasting with the deliberate, analytical, and planned approach described in the scenario.
D. Logical incrementalism describes a process of strategy evolving through small, experimental steps, which is different from the described comprehensive analysis of the external industry.

References

- Porter, M. E. (1980). Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors. Free Press. (This is the foundational text for the positioning approach, detailing how industry structure dictates competitive rules).

- Barney, J. B. (1991). Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99–120. https://doi.org/10.1177/014920639101700108 (This seminal paper defines the resource-based view, contrasting it directly with the positioning school's external focus).

- De Wit, B. (2020). Strategy: An International Perspective (7th ed.). Cengage. (Chapter 3, "The Strategy Formation Process," clearly distinguishes between the positioning school's analytical approach and other process views like emergent strategy and logical incrementalism).

Scroll to Top