CIMAPRA19-F02-1 practice question 17 of 35

XY has a weighted average cost of capital (WACC) of 10% based on its gearing level (measured as debt/debt+equity) of 40%.  It is considering a signficant new project. In which of the following situations would it be appropriate to appraise this project using XY's existing WACC of 10%?

Full set: 266 questions
Answer options
A: The project is in a different industry to XY's current operations and funded entirely by equity.
B: The project is an extension of XY's current operations and is funded 40% by debt and 60% by equity. Correct answer
C: The project is an extension of XY's current operations and is funded by equal amounts of debt and equity.
D: The project is in a different industry to XY's current operations and is funded by equal amounts of debt and equity.
Correct Answer:
B. The project is an extension of XY's current operations and is funded 40% by debt and 60% by equity.
Explanation

A company's existing Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) is an appropriate discount rate for a new project only if the project does not alter the company's overall risk profile. This requires two conditions to be met:
1. The project must have the same business risk as the company's existing operations.
2. The project must be financed in a way that maintains the company's current financial risk (i.e., its capital structure or gearing).
Option B is the only scenario that satisfies both conditions. The project is an "extension of XY's current operations," implying the same business risk. It is funded with 40% debt, which matches the company's existing gearing level, thus maintaining the same financial risk.

Why Incorrect

A. The project has different business risk (new industry) and financial risk (100% equity), making the existing WACC unsuitable.
C. While the business risk is similar, the financing (50% debt) alters the company's financial risk, requiring a recalculated WACC.
D. The project has different business risk (new industry) and financial risk (50% debt), invalidating the use of the existing WACC.

References

1. Brealey

R. A.

Myers

S. C.

& Allen

F. (2020). Principles of Corporate Finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education. In Chapter 9

Section 9-2

"The Company Cost of Capital

" it is explained that the company WACC is the correct discount rate only for projects that are "average risk" relative to the firm's other assets and that will not change the firm's target debt ratio.

2. Damodaran

A. (2012). Investment Valuation: Tools and Techniques for Determining the Value of Any Asset (3rd ed.). Wiley. In Chapter 7

"Cost of Capital

" it is stated that for a firm's WACC to be the correct project discount rate

the risk of the project must match the risk of the firm's existing assets

and the project's financing mix must be similar to that of the firm.

3. MIT OpenCourseWare. (2008). 15.401 Finance Theory I

Fall 2008. Lecture Notes

Lecture 9: "Risk and Return II: CAPM and APT". The notes clarify that the company cost of capital is appropriate for projects with the same risk as the company's existing assets. A project in a new industry would have a different risk profile.

Scroll to Top