CIMAPRA19-F03-1 practice question 2 of 35

A company has an opportunity to invest in a positive net present value project, but the project would require debt finance that would push the company's gearing ever a limit imposed by a debt covenant on an existing loan. Which THREE of the following actions could be taken by the company?

Full set: 390 questions
Answer options
A: The company could approach its existing Lenders to negotiate a relaxation of :he conditions imposed by the covenant. Correct answer
B: The project could be foregone if it cannot be funded without breaching the covenant Correct answer
C: The project could proceed if the cash inflows from the project will enable some of the debt to be repaid before the end of the financial year and so the breach of covenant may never be detected
D: The company could seek alternative sources of finding, such as a reduction in the annual dividend payment, to finance the project. Correct answer
E: The directors could meet with key shareholder to discuss whether they wish the project proceed despite the breach of the covenant
F: The directors could proceed will the project because their primary duly is maximise shared older wealth, even if that conflicts with lenders' interest.
Correct Answer:
A. The company could approach its existing Lenders to negotiate a relaxation of :he conditions imposed by the covenant.; B. The project could be foregone if it cannot be funded without breaching the covenant; D. The company could seek alternative sources of finding, such as a reduction in the annual dividend payment, to finance the project.
Explanation

When facing a potential breach of a debt covenant, a company must consider legitimate and responsible actions. Negotiating with lenders (A) is a primary and constructive step. If negotiations fail and no other solution is found, forgoing the positive NPV project (B) may be the only prudent option to avoid default. Seeking alternative, non-debt financing (D), such as using retained earnings by reducing dividends, directly addresses the gearing constraint without abandoning the project. These three options represent sound financial and ethical management.

Why Incorrect

C. Knowingly breaching a covenant and hoping it is not detected is unethical, potentially fraudulent, and risks triggering default clauses if discovered.
E. Shareholders cannot override a contractual agreement with lenders; their wishes are irrelevant to the legal obligation to adhere to the covenant.
F. The directors' duty to shareholders is not absolute and does not permit violating legal contracts with lenders, as this could lead to default and harm the company.

References

1. Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of Corporate Finance. 13th ed. McGraw-Hill Education. Chapter 18, Section 18-3, discusses debt covenants and the conflicts of interest between bondholders and stockholders, implying negotiation and adherence are key.

2. MIT OpenCourseWare. (2003). 15.414 Financial Management, Lecture Notes, Lecture 16: Capital Structure III. The lecture notes cover the role of debt covenants in controlling agency problems and the consequences of breaches, reinforcing that companies must actively manage these constraints.

Scroll to Top