CIMAPRA19-F03-1 practice question 1 of 35

A company is owned by its five directors who want to sell the business. Current profit after tax is $750,000. The directors are currently paid…

Full set: 390 questions
A company is owned by its five directors who want to sell the business. Current profit after tax is $750,000. The directors are currently paid minimal salaries, taking most of their incomes as dividends. After the company is sold, directors' salaries will need to be increased by $50,000 each year in total. A suitable Price/Earnings (P/E) ratio is 7, and the rate of corporate tax is 20%. What is the value of the company using a P/E valuation?
Answer options
A: $4,900,000
B: $5,250,000
C: $5,530,000
D: $4,970,000 Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. $4,970,000
Explanation

The valuation should be based on the company's future maintainable earnings from a new owner's perspective. The current profit after tax of $750,000 must be adjusted for the necessary increase in directors' salaries, which are a pre-tax expense. The additional salary expense of $50,000 reduces pre-tax profit. This reduction in profit creates a tax shield of 20% ($50,000 0.20 = $10,000). Therefore, the net reduction in post-tax profit is $40,000 ($50,000 - $10,000). The maintainable earnings are $710,000 ($750,000 - $40,000). Applying the P/E ratio of 7 gives a valuation of $4,970,000 ($710,000 7).

Why Incorrect

A. This incorrectly subtracts the full pre-tax salary increase from the post-tax profit, ignoring the tax shield effect.
B. This uses the unadjusted profit figure, failing to account for the necessary increase in salaries under new ownership.
C. This figure does not correspond to a logical calculation based on the provided data and standard valuation principles.

References

1. Pinto, J. E., Henry, E., Robinson, T. R., & Stowe, J. D. (2015). Equity Asset Valuation (3rd ed.). Wiley. Chapter 4, "Price and Enterprise Value Multiples," discusses the importance of using normalized or underlying earnings, which involves adjusting for non-recurring or non-standard items like owner-manager salaries.

2. University of Manchester, Alliance Manchester Business School. (Courseware). BMAN30071 Corporate Finance. The course materials on business valuation emphasize the concept of "maintainable earnings" or "normalized earnings" as the basis for applying valuation multiples like the P/E ratio.

Scroll to Top