CIMAPRO19-P02-1 practice question 24 of 30

The performance report for the production manager of a company for the last month included the following. 1,000 direct labor hours were worked at a…

Full set: 202 questions
The performance report for the production manager of a company for the last month included the following. 1,000 direct labor hours were worked at a basic rate of pay of $10 per hour. 200 of these hours were worked during overtime for which a 30% overtime premium was paid. 80 of these overtime hours were to fulfill a customer order that had originally been planned for manufacture next month. The sales manager had agreed to bring forward the delivery of this order at the request of the customer. The remaining overtime hours were due to unexpected inefficiency of the workforce; this has been traced to poor supervision by a junior manager. Material costs included the following: $5,300 of material
Answer options
A: Material A is a commodity and, due to changes on the global market, the actual unit cost of this material for last month was 6% higher than had been expected $5,250 of material B. The usage of material B last month was 5% higher than it should have been due to faulty workmanship on the production line. What is the total value of the above costs that was controllable by the production manager? Correct answer
B: $20,610
C: $19,810
D: $20,910
E: $20,360
Correct Answer:
A. Material A is a commodity and, due to changes on the global market, the actual unit cost of this material for last month was 6% higher than had been expected $5,250 of material B. The usage of material B last month was 5% higher than it should have been due to faulty workmanship on the production line. What is the total value of the above costs that was controllable by the production manager?
Explanation

The calculation is based on the principle of controllability, which states that managers should only be held accountable for costs they can directly influence. Controllable Labour Cost: The basic pay for all hours worked (1,000 hours × $10 = $10,000) is controllable. The overtime premium due to inefficiency (120 hours × $10 × 30% = $360) is also controllable as it stems from poor supervision within the department. The premium for the sales request (80 hours) is not controllable by the production manager. Controllable Material A Cost: The 6% price increase is due to external market factors and is uncontrollable by the production manager. Therefore, only the standard cost portion is controllable: $5,300 / 1.06 = $5,000. Controllable Material B Cost: The entire cost of $5,250 is controllable because the excess usage was due to faulty workmanship, a factor within the production manager's control. Total Controllable Cost = $10,000 (Basic Labour) + $360 (Controllable OT) + $5,000 (Material A) + $5,250 (Material B) = $20,610.

Why Incorrect

B. $19,810: This figure is derived from an incorrect combination of controllable and uncontrollable items, likely omitting key controllable costs like the standard cost of Material A.
C. $20,910: This incorrectly includes the uncontrollable market price variance for Material A ($300), treating the full $5,300 cost as controllable by the production manager.
D. $20,360: This incorrectly treats the adverse usage variance for Material B ($250) as uncontrollable, including only its standard cost ($5,000) rather than the full amount. ---

References

1. Drury

C. (2018). Management and Cost Accounting (10th ed.). Cengage Learning. In Chapter 19

"Divisional financial performance measures

" the concept of controllable profit is discussed

emphasizing that divisional managers should be evaluated based on costs and revenues they can control. The distinction between a controllable cost (e.g.

material usage) and an uncontrollable cost (e.g.

market price changes) is a core principle (pp. 588-590).

2. Horngren

C. T.

Datar

S. M.

& Rajan

M. V. (2017). Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis (16th ed.). Pearson. Chapter 6

"Master Budget and Responsibility Accounting

" defines a controllable cost as "any cost that is primarily subject to the influence of a given responsibility center manager for a given period" (p. 205). The text provides examples showing that a production manager controls material usage but not market prices

and is responsible for overtime caused by poor scheduling.

3. CIMA (2017). Official Terminology. Chartered Institute of Management Accountants. The definition of 'Controllable Cost' is provided as: "A cost which can be influenced by the decisions of a manager." This official definition directly supports the logic used to separate costs influenced by the production manager (inefficiency

material usage) from those that are not (sales requests

market prices).

Scroll to Top