CIPP-A practice question 1 of 15

Besides the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA), which of the following is a potential source of privacy protection for Singapore citizens?

Full set: 90 questions
Answer options
A: Constitutional protections of personal information.
B: International agreements protecting privacy.
C: The tort of invasion of privacy.
D: Breach of confidence law. Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. Breach of confidence law.
Explanation

Besides the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA), the common law action for breach of confidence is a significant source of privacy protection in Singapore. This long-standing equitable doctrine protects information that possesses the "quality of confidence" and was imparted in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence. The Singapore Court of Appeal has affirmed and even modified this doctrine to address modern privacy concerns, making it applicable to the wrongful use or disclosure of confidential personal information. It operates alongside the PDPA to provide a distinct legal remedy for individuals whose confidential information has been misused, sometimes covering gaps not addressed by the statutory regime.

Why Incorrect

A. Constitutional protections of personal information. The Constitution of the Republic of Singapore does not contain an express or implied standalone right to privacy or the protection of personal information.
B. International agreements protecting privacy. While Singapore participates in frameworks like the APEC CBPR, these primarily facilitate cross-border data flows and do not create a direct, independent cause of action for citizens.
C. The tort of invasion of privacy. Singaporean courts have consistently declined to recognize a general, standalone tort of invasion of privacy, preferring to rely on established actions like breach of confidence. ---

References

1. For Correct Answer (D) and Incorrect Answer (C):

I-Admin (Singapore) Pte Ltd v Hong Ying Ting and others [2020] 1 SLR 1130. In this landmark decision, the Singapore Court of Appeal reformed the law on breach of confidence, stating at [59] that an action for breach of confidence would be established if "(a) the information was confidential... and (b) the information was imparted in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence," and then considering if the conscience of the recipient was affected. This case affirms the doctrine's central role in protecting confidential information, which is a cornerstone of privacy. The judgment also implicitly confirms the non-existence of a general privacy tort by focusing on developing the breach of confidence action.

2. For Incorrect Answer (A):

Thio, Li-ann. "Constitutionalising the Right to Privacy in Singapore." Singapore Journal of Legal Studies, 2019, pp. 424–460. This academic paper analyzes the constitutional position in Singapore, concluding, "Singapore’s written constitution does not expressly protect a right to privacy" (p. 424) and that judicial interpretation has not established such a right.

3. For Incorrect Answer (C):

Chik, Warren B. "The Tort of Misuse of Private Information and the Right to Privacy in Singapore." Singapore Academy of Law Journal, vol. 25, 2013, pp. 436-469. This article (at para 1) notes the Singapore High Court's statement in Malcomson Nicholas Hugh Bertram v Mehta Naresh Kumar [2001] 4 SLR 454 that "it was not plain and obvious that the law in Singapore does not recognise a tort of invasion of privacy," but subsequent case law has not developed this into a recognized tort, with courts preferring to use the breach of confidence framework.

Scroll to Top