CIPP-A practice question 4 of 15

SCENARIO – Please use the following to answer the next QUESTION: Singabank is a boutique bank in Singapore. After being notified during the hiring…

Full set: 90 questions
SCENARIO – Please use the following to answer the next QUESTION: Singabank is a boutique bank in Singapore. After being notified during the hiring process, Singabank employees are subject to constant and thorough monitoring and tracking through CCTV cameras, computer monitoring software and keyboard loggers. Singabank does this to ensure its employees are complying with Singabank's data security policy. Bigbank is now considering acquiring Singabank's retail banking division. As part of its due diligence, Bigbank is seeking for Singabank to disclose to it all of its surveillance material on its employees, whether or not they are part of the retail banking division. Jimmy works in Singabank's investment banking division. Assuming the monitoring was legal, can Singabank disclose Jimmy's personal data to Bigbank?
Answer options
A: No, because Jimmy is not in the division that Bigbank seeks to acquire. Correct answer
B: No, because the data was collected for the express purpose of complying with Singabank's privacy policies.
C: Yes, if Singabank informs Jimmy of the disclosure of his personal data before it occurs.
D: Yes, if Jimmy's personal data is necessary for Bigbank to determine whether to proceed with the acquisition.
Correct Answer:
A. No, because Jimmy is not in the division that Bigbank seeks to acquire.
Explanation

The disclosure is for the purpose of due diligence related to the acquisition of Singabank's retail banking division. Jimmy works in the investment banking division. Under Singapore's Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA), the "business asset transaction" exception allows for the disclosure of personal data without consent if it is necessary for the other party to determine whether to proceed with the transaction. As Jimmy is not part of the division being acquired, the disclosure of his personal surveillance data is not necessary for Bigbank's due diligence. Therefore, disclosing his data would be excessive and would not be permitted under this exception.

Why Incorrect

B. While the purpose has changed, this is not the most precise reason. The PDPA has exceptions, like the business asset transaction exception, that can permit disclosure for a new purpose without fresh consent.
C. Merely informing Jimmy is insufficient. This new purpose requires fresh consent. While notification is part of the "deemed consent by notification" process, it also requires giving the individual an opportunity to opt out, which is not stated here.
D. This states the correct legal test ("necessary") for the business asset transaction exception. However, based on the facts, Jimmy's data is not necessary for a due diligence exercise on the retail banking division. ---

References

1. Personal Data Protection Act 2012 (Singapore Statues Online):

Section 18 (Purpose Limitation Obligation): "An organisation may collect, use or disclose personal data about an individual only for purposes that a reasonable person would consider appropriate in the circumstances and that the individual has been informed of..."

First Schedule, Section 3 (Definition of business asset transaction): Defines the scope of such transactions.

Second Schedule, Part 3, Paragraph (1)(a): States that personal data can be disclosed to a prospective party of a business asset transaction if the "personal data is necessary for the prospective party to determine whether to proceed with the transaction". This directly supports why Jimmy's data, being from an unrelated division, cannot be disclosed under this exception.

2. Personal Data Protection Commission (PDPC) Singapore, Advisory Guidelines on the PDPA for Selected Topics (Revised 1 Feb 2021):

Chapter 2: Business Asset Transactions, Paragraph 2.10: "The personal data disclosed must be necessary for the prospective party to determine whether to proceed with the business asset transaction. Organisations should not disclose personal data that is not relevant for this purpose." This guideline reinforces that only relevant and necessary data can be disclosed, making the disclosure of Jimmy's data impermissible.

3. Chesterman, S. (2014). Data Protection in Singapore: The Personal Data Protection Act 2012. Singapore Academy of Law Journal, 26, 698-731.

Page 715, Section on "Business asset transactions": Discusses the exception, noting that the data must be "necessary for the other party to determine whether to proceed with the transaction." The analysis emphasizes that this exception is not a blanket permission and is constrained by necessity, which aligns with the reasoning that data from an uninvolved division would fail this test.

Scroll to Top