CPTD practice question 13 of 15

[Organizational Capability] An organization with high turnover had attempted to reduce turnover by increasing wages and paid time off. A year later, the turnover rate had not changed. Which is the best approach for solving the issue?

Full set: 90 questions

Domain Impacting Organizational Capability

Answer options
A: Complexity theory
B: Systems thinking Correct answer
C: Organizational change theory
D: Six Sigma
Correct Answer:
B. Systems thinking
Explanation

The organization's initial attempt to solve high turnover by increasing wages failed because it addressed a single symptom in isolation. This indicates a lack of understanding of the problem's root cause. Systems thinking is the most appropriate approach because it views the organization as a complex system of interconnected parts (e.g., culture, leadership, job design, career paths). By applying systems thinking, the organization can analyze the relationships and feedback loops between these parts to identify the multiple, underlying factors contributing to turnover, leading to a more effective and holistic solution.

Why Incorrect

A. Complexity theory: This is a broader framework for understanding unpredictable, emergent behavior in adaptive systems, which is less direct for diagnosing this specific organizational issue.
C. Organizational change theory: This focuses on the process of implementing change (e.g., Kotter's model), which is a later step; the immediate need is to correctly diagnose the problem.
D. Six Sigma: This is a data-driven process improvement methodology for reducing defects and variation, which is less suitable for diagnosing complex, human-centric issues like turnover.

References

1. Association for Talent Development. (2020). The ATD Talent Development Body of Knowledge (TDBoK). In the "Performance Improvement" capability, the TDBoK emphasizes the use of systemic thinking to diagnose performance gaps. It states that practitioners must "apply systems thinking to organizational challenges" and understand that issues are often the result of multiple, interacting components within the organizational system, not isolated causes (Section 2.3.1, Analyzing Performance Gaps). The scenario exemplifies a failed non-systemic approach.

2. Senge, P. M. (2006). The Fifth Discipline: The Art & Practice of The Learning Organization. Doubleday. Senge describes a core systems thinking principle: "shifting the burden." The organization shifted the burden of solving a deep issue (e.g., poor culture or management) to a simple, symptomatic solution (more money). Systems thinking helps uncover the underlying structures causing the problem instead of focusing on short-term, symptomatic fixes (Chapter 8: The Archetype of Shifting the Burden).

3. Rothwell, W. J., & Kazanas, H. C. (2003). Planning and Managing Human Resources: Strategic Planning for Personnel Management. University of Massachusetts Press. This text discusses organizational diagnosis, explaining that effective interventions require a systemic view. It notes that problems like turnover are rarely attributable to a single cause like compensation but are embedded in the broader organizational system, including job satisfaction, supervision, and organizational commitment (Chapter 4: Diagnosing Organizational Needs).

Scroll to Top