CPTD practice question 9 of 15

[Professional Capability] A talent development professional has been asked to provide feedback to a trainer about an in- person session that received…

Full set: 90 questions

Domain Developing Professional Capability

[Professional Capability] A talent development professional has been asked to provide feedback to a trainer about an in- person session that received poor evaluation responses. The training was for senior-level management to learn to be more strategic and collaborative in their annual planning session. The trainer presented the learners with theories and methods for strategic planning and how to collaborate. Survey responses revealed learners felt they had not learned what they expected to learn. What was the most likely problem?
Answer options
A: The presentations were not polished enough, and the trainer should have practiced more before the session
B: The learners were not motivated to learn the content presented to them and did not see how it related to the task at hand
C: The training did not take into account the fact that the learners were experienced and motivated to learn
D: The training did not provide situations where the learners could practice working as a group to come up with strategic priorities Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. The training did not provide situations where the learners could practice working as a group to come up with strategic priorities
Explanation

The target audience is senior-level management, who, according to adult learning principles (andragogy), are experienced, self-directed, and problem-centered learners. They require learning that is immediately applicable to their work. The training objective was to learn a skill: "to be more strategic and collaborative." Presenting only theories and methods is a passive, knowledge-based approach. For skill acquisition, especially for this audience, active practice is essential. The learners felt they hadn't learned what they expected because they were not given the opportunity to apply the concepts in a practical, collaborative setting, which is how they would build the intended capability.

Why Incorrect

A. While presentation polish is important, the core feedback was about the failure to learn, not the quality of the delivery style itself.
B. Senior leaders are generally highly motivated for training directly tied to a critical business process like annual planning, making a lack of motivation unlikely.
C. This is a valid general statement, but option D provides the specific, critical failure that resulted from not considering their experience and learning needs.

References

1. Knowles, M. S., Holton, E. F., & Swanson, R. A. (2015). The adult learner: The definitive classic in adult education and human resource development (8th ed.). This foundational text on andragogy emphasizes that adults are problem-centered and need to apply learning immediately. The scenario violates the principle that adults learn best through experience, including practice and application (Chapter 4, "Andragogy: The Art and Science of Helping Adults Learn").

2. Association for Talent Development. (2020). ATD Talent Development Body of Knowledge (TDBoK). The "Instructional Design" capability section emphasizes selecting instructional methods that align with learning objectives and audience characteristics. For a skill-based objective ("be more...collaborative") with an experienced audience, methods like case studies, simulations, and role-playing are appropriate, not just presentations (Part 3, Chapter 10: Instructional Design).

3. Kolb, D. A. (2015). Experiential learning: Experience as the source of learning and development (2nd ed.). Kolb's experiential learning cycle posits that effective learning involves concrete experience and active experimentation. The described training remained at the "Abstract Conceptualization" stage (presenting theories) and failed to move to "Active Experimentation" (practice), which is crucial for learning transfer. (Chapter 3, "The Process of Experiential Learning").

Scroll to Top