DCPP-01 practice question 21 of 25

A team created by the Indian government has been assigned to create India's privacy law based on Justice AP Shah's recommendations. Is any of the following legislation necessary?

Full set: 122 questions
Answer options
A: National privacy principles Correct answer
B: An official national data controller registry should be created
C: Penalties, remedies, and offenses
D: A right to privacy that is explicitly enshrined in the constitution
Correct Answer:
A. National privacy principles
Explanation

The central and most foundational recommendation of the Group of Experts on Privacy, chaired by Justice A.P. Shah, was the establishment of a set of nine "National Privacy Principles." These principles were intended to form the core of India's proposed privacy legislation. They provided a comprehensive framework covering aspects like notice, consent, collection and purpose limitation, data security, and accountability. The entire proposed law was structured around the implementation and enforcement of these fundamental principles, making them the most necessary legislative component recommended by the committee.

Why Incorrect

B. The report recommended the establishment of a Privacy Commissioner for enforcement and oversight, not the creation of a mandatory national registry for data controllers.
C. While the report did recommend an enforcement framework that included penalties and remedies, the National Privacy Principles were the substantive legal foundation upon which such enforcement mechanisms would act.
D. The committee's mandate was to recommend a legislative framework (a law/statute), not to propose a constitutional amendment to explicitly enshrine the right to privacy.

References

1. Government of India, Planning Commission. (2012, October 16). Report of the Group of Experts on Privacy. Chaired by Justice A. P. Shah.

Reference: Chapter V, "The Proposed Privacy Act," Section 5.2, "The National Privacy Principles," pp. 38-40. This section explicitly lists and details the nine principles as the "backbone of the proposed privacy legislation."

Reference: Chapter VI, "The Privacy Commissioner and Enforcement," pp. 68-75. This chapter details the enforcement structure, including penalties, but these are consequential to the principles outlined in Chapter V.

2. Raman, U., & Sharma, V. (2018). Privacy in India: A review of the legal framework. International Journal of Law and Information Technology, 26(3), 230–253.

Reference: Page 239, Section 3.2, "The A.P. Shah Committee Report." The article states, "The most significant contribution of the Report was the enunciation of nine National Privacy Principles which were to form the bedrock of the proposed privacy law."

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/ijlit/eay007

3. Data Security Council of India (DSCI). (2018). DSCI Privacy Framework (DPF©).

Reference: The DPF© framework itself is heavily influenced by and often references the principles laid out in the A.P. Shah Committee report as a foundational step in India's privacy journey. The DCPP-01 certification is based on this body of knowledge, which recognizes the primacy of these principles in the report's recommendations.

Scroll to Top