DCPP-01 practice question 12 of 25

Which of the following statements is true in respect of the India specific government projects such as Aadhaar, National Population Register (NPR), etc. that can have privacy implications?

Full set: 122 questions
Answer options
A: Collection of biometrics in India is a statutory requirement
B: Proper and adequate notification is not provided to data subjects before and during the collection of their personal information
C: Data subjects are not limited in their ability to exercise control over the ways their personal information is being used, once it has been shared by them as part of the projects Correct answer
D: Citizens are being given the choice to opt out from submitting their biometric details and are allowed to complete the environment without submitting their biometrics
Correct Answer:
C. Data subjects are not limited in their ability to exercise control over the ways their personal information is being used, once it has been shared by them as part of the projects
Explanation

This statement is considered true within the context of the functionalities provided by the governing bodies. For instance, the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) provides Aadhaar holders with specific tools to manage their data. These include the ability to view their authentication history, lock and unlock their biometrics, and update demographic information through the official portal. While broader control over data usage, purpose limitation, or the right to erasure is severely restricted, the existence of these specific control mechanisms is interpreted to mean that the data subject's ability to exercise control is not entirely absent or limited to zero.

Why Incorrect

A. The Supreme Court has ruled against universal mandatory collection of biometrics, limiting its requirement to specific government benefits and services, making this statement overly broad.
B. This is factually incorrect. Enrollment processes for projects like Aadhaar have mandated procedures for informing individuals about the data being collected through forms and enrollment operators.
D. This is false. The Supreme Court has upheld the mandatory nature of Aadhaar for receiving certain government subsidies and filing income tax returns, removing a general choice to opt-out.

References

1. The Aadhaar (Targeted Delivery of Financial and Other Subsidies, Benefits and Services) Act, 2016. Chapter VI, Section 28-32, outlines the "Protection of Information," including the responsibilities of the UIDAI and the rights of Aadhaar number holders to access and alter their own information. This provides the statutory basis for the control mechanisms mentioned in the explanation.

2. Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) Official Website. The "My Aadhaar Services" section of the UIDAI portal (uidai.gov.in) officially documents the services available to Aadhaar holders, including "Aadhaar Lock/Unlock" and "Authentication History." These services are the basis for the argument that users are "not limited" in their ability to exercise some control.

3. Justice K. S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) & Anr. vs Union Of India & Ors., (2019) 1 SCC 1. The Supreme Court's judgment on Aadhaar is a critical source. The ruling read down Section 57, invalidating mandatory Aadhaar for private services, which refutes the universal statutory requirement claimed in option A. It also upheld Section 7 for subsidies, refuting the general opt-out claimed in option D. (See paragraphs on Section 57 and Section 7 analysis).

Scroll to Top