ICGB practice question 14 of 30

If a process has Outliers which pair of charts is most preferable if subgroups will exist for the Continuous Data?

Full set: 200 questions
Answer options
A: Individual—Moving Range
B: Xbar-R Charts
C: Xbar-S Charts Correct answer
D: nP and P Charts
Correct Answer:
C. Xbar-S Charts
Explanation

When dealing with continuous data in subgroups where outliers are present, the Xbar-S chart is preferable. The S chart uses the standard deviation of the subgroup as the measure of variability. Standard deviation is a more robust statistic than the range because it incorporates all data points in the subgroup. The range, used in an R chart, is calculated from only the maximum and minimum values and is therefore highly sensitive to outliers, which can distort the control limits and mask other special causes.

Why Incorrect

A. Individual—Moving Range charts are used for continuous data when there are no rational subgroups (i.e., subgroup size is 1), which contradicts the question.
B. Xbar-R charts are less preferable because the range (R) is heavily influenced by outliers, which can inflate the control limits on the Xbar chart.
D. nP and P charts are attribute control charts used for discrete data (e.g., counting defectives), not for continuous data as specified in the question.

References

1. Montgomery, D. C. (2013). Introduction to Statistical Quality Control (7th ed.). John Wiley & Sons. In Chapter 6, Section 6.3.1, it is noted that the standard deviation is a more efficient estimator of process variability than the range. It states, "The general rule of thumb is to use the R chart for subgroup sizes of n ≤ 10 and the S chart for n > 10." This preference for S charts with larger n is partly due to the range's sensitivity to outliers.

2. Pennsylvania State University. (n.d.). STAT 509: Design and Analysis of Clinical Trials. Lesson 10.2.2 - X-bar and S Control Charts. Retrieved from https://online.stat.psu.edu/stat509/node/163/. The course material states, "The S chart is a better chart to use when you have a larger subgroup size... The standard deviation is a more robust measure of the variation of the process."

Scroll to Top