ICGB practice question 9 of 30

Which statement(s) describe an undesirable situation when implementing SPC?

Full set: 200 questions
Answer options
A: The lower Control Limit for the R chart is equal to zero
B: Attempt to use SPC for tracking transaction times at a warehouse
C: A process is in Statistical Control before implementation of SPC
D: The Control Limits are wider than the customer specification limits Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. The Control Limits are wider than the customer specification limits
Explanation

This situation describes a process that is not capable of meeting customer requirements. Control Limits represent the 'voice of the process' (its natural variation), while specification limits represent the 'voice of the customer' (the required performance). If the process variation is wider than the customer's tolerance, the process will inherently produce a significant number of defects. This indicates a low process capability (Cpk < 1.0) and is a highly undesirable state that SPC would highlight.

Why Incorrect

A. A Lower Control Limit (LCL) of zero on an R chart is a common and expected mathematical result for small subgroup sizes and is not inherently undesirable.
B. Transaction times are continuous data, and using SPC to monitor their stability and performance is a perfectly valid and desirable application.
C. A process being in statistical control is the ideal state. SPC is used to verify this stability and monitor the process to ensure it remains in control.

References

1. Montgomery, D. C. (2013). Introduction to Statistical Quality Control (7th ed.). John Wiley & Sons. In Chapter 7, Section 7.2.3, "Process Capability Ratios," it is explained that when the process spread (6σ, which is the basis for control limits) is greater than the specification spread (USL - LSL), the process is not capable.

2. University of Alabama in Huntsville. (n.d.). ISE 426/526 Statistical Quality Control and Improvement: Chapter 5 - Process and Measurement System Capability Analysis. Retrieved from http://www.eng.uah.edu/~rg-me/sqc/sqc5.pdf. Slide 5-5 illustrates that if the "Natural Tolerance Limits" (based on process variation) are outside the "Specification Limits," the process is not capable.

Scroll to Top