ICYB practice question 4 of 25

A Belt has determined that the loan application does not need to be reviewed by accounting thereby improving the number of applications a loan processer can handle. According to Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) definitions RTY improvement would be considered _______________.

Full set: 120 questions
Answer options
A: Downsizing savings
B: Hard savings Correct answer
C: Soft savings
D: Median savings
Correct Answer:
B. Hard savings
Explanation

The improvement described is a tangible, measurable increase in productivity—more loan applications are processed without increasing resources. This directly impacts the organization's bottom line, either through increased revenue from processing more loans or through reduced labor costs per application. In Lean Six Sigma financial accounting, such direct, quantifiable financial gains that are reflected in the profit and loss (P&L) statement are classified as "Hard savings." The improvement in Rolled Throughput Yield (RTY) signifies a more efficient process with less waste, the financial benefit of which is realized as a hard saving.

Why Incorrect

A. Downsizing savings: This is a specific type of hard saving, but it is not the only possible outcome. The increased capacity could be used to grow business rather than reduce staff.
C. Soft savings: These are intangible or difficult-to-quantify benefits, such as improved employee morale or enhanced customer satisfaction, which do not directly appear on financial statements.
D. Median savings: This is not a standard, recognized category for classifying financial benefits in the context of Lean Six Sigma or Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ). ---

References

1. Purdue University Manufacturing Extension Partnership. (n.d.). Lean Six Sigma Green Belt Certification Training. In the module discussing project financial benefits, hard savings are defined as "actual cash flow improvements that can be found on the P&L statement," including productivity gains, while soft savings are defined as "cost avoidance or potential for future savings." The scenario directly describes a productivity gain. (Reference: Purdue University, Technical Assistance Program course materials on Lean Six Sigma).

2. Antony, J., Kumar, M., & Madu, C. N. (2005). Six Sigma in service organisations: Benefits, challenges and difficulties, common myths, and conditions for success. International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, 22(3), 294-311. This article discusses the financial outcomes of Six Sigma projects, distinguishing between hard savings ("directly traceable to the bottom-line of the organisation") and soft savings ("difficult to measure in financial terms"). The described productivity improvement is a direct, traceable benefit. (DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/02656710510582493, Section: "Benefits of Six Sigma in service organisations").

3. IASSC Certified Lean Six Sigma Yellow Belt Body of Knowledge (ICYB BOK). (2023). The BOK outlines the financial evaluation of projects within the Measure phase. It defines Hard Savings as verifiable, bottom-line impacts such as cost reduction and revenue enhancement. Soft Savings are defined as improvements not immediately hitting the P&L, like cost avoidance. The scenario's increased capacity is a direct driver for cost reduction or revenue enhancement, aligning with the definition of Hard Savings. (Reference: IASSC ICYB BOK, Section 3.0 Measure Phase, subsection on Project Metrics).

Scroll to Top