ICYB practice question 3 of 25

The “Equipment” category of Root Causes on a Fishbone Diagram would be used primarily used to generate ideas as to which of the following are possible causes for defects?

Full set: 120 questions
Answer options
A: Out of calibration measurement system
B: Tolerance changes in milling machines
C: Worn bearings on a shaft
D: All of these answers are correct Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. All of these answers are correct
Explanation

The Fishbone (or Ishikawa) Diagram is a cause-and-effect tool used to identify potential root causes for a specific problem. The "Equipment" category, also known as "Machine," is designated for brainstorming causes related to the tools, machinery, and technology used in the process. All the provided options represent valid potential causes that fall under this category. An out-of-calibration measurement system (A), changes in machine tolerance (B), and worn mechanical components like bearings (C) are all classic examples of equipment-related issues that can directly lead to process variation and defects. Therefore, all listed answers are correct examples for this category.

Why Incorrect

A: This option is incomplete. While a correct example, it excludes other valid equipment-related causes listed in options B and C. B: This option is incomplete. While a correct example, it excludes other valid equipment-related causes listed in options A and C. C: This option is incomplete. While a correct example, it excludes other valid equipment-related causes listed in options A and B.

References

1. IASSC Certified Lean Six Sigma Yellow Belt Body of Knowledge (BOK):

Reference: Section 3.2.2, Cause & Effect / Fishbone Diagram.

Content: The official IASSC BOK specifies the 6M categories for the Fishbone Diagram, including "Machine" (Equipment). This category is defined to include all causes related to the equipment, tools, and facilities used in the process, which directly supports that tool wear, calibration, and machine settings are relevant inputs.

2. University Courseware:

Reference: MIT OpenCourseWare, 16.842 "Fundamentals of Systems Engineering," Fall 2015, Lecture 10: Root Cause Analysis.

Content: The lecture notes on root cause analysis tools describe the Ishikawa diagram's categories. The "Machine" category is shown to include factors like equipment maintenance, tooling, and calibration, which aligns with all three options (A, B, and C) being valid examples.

3. Peer-Reviewed Academic Publication:

Reference: Ishii, K. (2004). ME317: Design for Manufacturability, Course Notes, Chapter 6: Process Control and Improvement. Stanford University.

Content: In Chapter 6, Section 6.2, "Cause and Effect Diagram," Professor Ishii provides examples for the "Machine" category, including "machine wear," "improper setting," and "maintenance." These examples directly correspond to worn bearings (wear), tolerance changes (setting), and calibration status (maintenance).

Scroll to Top