IIA-CIA-PART1 practice question 33 of 35

A chief audit executive (CAE) has just joined an organization with an existing internal audit activity. Based on her review of the current organizational structure, the CAE determines that the internal audit activity lacks adequate independence. Which of the following actions is the CAE's best step to take next to move the internal audit activity toward organizational independence?

Full set: 735 questions
Answer options
A: Ensure the limitations are disclosed through communication with the board and senior management, so that the internal audit activity can continue operating under the same organizational structure.
B: Request that the board restructure the reporting line of the internal audit activity to ensure the CAE has unrestricted access to the board. Correct answer
C: Rotate internal audit assignments among members of the internal audit activity to minimize the effects of the current structure.
D: Train internal auditors about organizational independence and have them sign an acknowledgment of understanding.
Correct Answer:
B. Request that the board restructure the reporting line of the internal audit activity to ensure the CAE has unrestricted access to the board.
Explanation

Organizational independence is a cornerstone of an effective internal audit activity and is primarily achieved through the reporting structure. According to the IIA's International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing (the Standards), the chief audit executive (CAE) must report to a level within the organization that allows the internal audit activity to fulfill its responsibilities without interference. The ideal structure involves a direct functional reporting line to the board or its audit committee. By requesting the board to restructure the reporting line, the CAE directly addresses the root cause of the impairment, taking the most effective and appropriate step to achieve the necessary organizational independence.

Why Incorrect

A. Disclosing the limitation is a required action if an impairment exists and cannot be resolved, but it is not the best first step to correct the underlying structural problem. The goal is to fix the issue, not just report it.
C. Rotating assignments is a technique to enhance individual auditor objectivity and mitigate familiarity threats. It does not address the fundamental, organization-wide lack of independence caused by an improper reporting structure.
D. Training staff on independence is important, but it does not resolve a structural impairment. The problem is with the internal audit activity's position in the organization, not the staff's understanding of the concept.

References

1. The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA), International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing (Standards), 2017.

Standard 1110 – Organizational Independence: "The chief audit executive must report to a level within the organization that allows the internal audit activity to fulfill its responsibilities. The chief audit executive must confirm to the board, at least annually, the organizational independence of the internal audit activity."

Implementation Guide 1110: "Organizational independence is effectively achieved when the chief audit executive reports functionally to the board... A functional reporting line to the board involves the board... making appropriate inquiries of management and the chief audit executive to determine whether there are inappropriate scope or resource limitations." This guidance directly supports that correcting the reporting line is the primary mechanism for achieving independence.

2. Pickett, K. H. Spencer. The Internal Auditing Handbook. 3rd ed., John Wiley & Sons, 2010.

Chapter 5, Section 5.4.2, "Reporting Lines": "To be truly independent, the head of internal audit (or CAE) should have a direct reporting line to the audit committee... This reporting line is the single most important factor when determining the independence of the function... If the CAE finds that the reporting line is not conducive to independence, he or she should raise the matter with the audit committee." (p. 89). This academic text confirms that addressing the reporting line with the board/audit committee is the correct action.

3. Moeller, Robert R. Brink's Modern Internal Auditing. 8th ed., John Wiley & Sons, 2016.

Chapter 3, "The Internal Audit Charter, Independence, and the Audit Committee": "The CAE should have direct and private access to the audit committee for all matters the CAE determines are necessary... If the CAE feels that the internal audit function’s independence is being threatened or compromised, the CAE should have the ability to go directly to the audit committee chair to discuss the matter." (p. 58). This reinforces that the CAE's primary recourse for independence issues is direct communication with the board/audit committee to seek structural resolution.

Scroll to Top