IIA-CIA-PART1 practice question 32 of 35

During a procurement process audit the internal audit activity undertakes a fraud risk assessment and considers a range of possible fraud scenarios within the process. Which of the following scenarios constitutes a pressure to commit fraud?

Full set: 735 questions
Answer options
A: An employee believes his poor compensation package justifies engaging in unethical behavior.
B: The head of the department is the only signatory to purchase orders issued to third party contractors.
C: Some employees strongly believe monetary gifts from vendors is a means of saving for life after employment.
D: One of the employees was found to have an obsession with expensive jewelry Correct answer
Correct Answer:
D. One of the employees was found to have an obsession with expensive jewelry
Explanation

The question asks to identify the scenario representing "pressure," one of the three components of the fraud triangle (Pressure, Opportunity, Rationalization). Pressure is the motivation or incentive that drives an individual to commit fraud. An employee's obsession with expensive jewelry creates a significant financial need to support that lifestyle, which may exceed their legitimate income. This situation creates a direct financial pressure on the individual to seek illicit funds, thereby constituting the "pressure" element of the fraud triangle.

Why Incorrect

A. This scenario primarily describes rationalization. The employee's belief that their poor compensation justifies unethical behavior is a mental justification for committing fraud, which is the definition of rationalization.
B. This describes an opportunity to commit fraud. The head of the department being the sole signatory represents a severe internal control weakness, specifically a lack of segregation of duties, which creates the ability to perpetrate and conceal fraud.
C. This is a clear example of rationalization. The employees are justifying the unethical act of accepting gifts (potential kickbacks) by reframing it as a legitimate "means of saving," thus making the fraudulent behavior seem acceptable to themselves.

References

1. The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA). Sawyer's Guide for Internal Auditors, 7th Ed., The IIA Research Foundation, 2019. Chapter 16, "Fraud Risks and Controls," discusses the fraud triangle. It identifies pressures as financial needs, such as "living beyond one's means" or "a desire for personal gain," which directly aligns with an obsession for expensive items.

2. Albrecht, W. S., Albrecht, C. O., & Zimbelman, M. F. (2016). Fraud Examination, 5th Ed. Cengage Learning. In Chapter 3, "Why People Commit Fraud," the authors list financial pressures as a key motivator. Examples include "greed," "living beyond one's means," and "high personal debt," all of which can be caused by an obsession with expensive goods.

3. Cressey, D. R. (1953). Other People's Money: A Study in the Social Psychology of Embezzlement. Patterson Smith. Cressey's foundational research identifies a "non-shareable financial problem" as the primary pressure. A need to fund an expensive obsession that cannot be shared with others for fear of judgment is a classic example of this pressure.

4. The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA). Practice Guide: Fraud and Internal Audit, 2nd Ed., 2016. This guide details the fraud triangle and provides examples for each component. Under "Incentive/Pressure," it lists factors like "Personal financial problems" and "Addictions," which are analogous to the pressure created by an expensive obsession. In contrast, it lists "Attitude/Rationalization" examples like "The organization owes me."

Scroll to Top